We're looking for contributors


Joss Whedon The Avengers Chris Hemsworth Thor
The Avengers director Joss Whedon, Chris Hemsworth Thor

The Avengers has broken all opening-weekend box office records in history. Well, maybe not all. But hyperbole aside, The Avengers has broken the official opening-weekend box office record in North America. Apparently, by a wide margin.

According to studio estimates, the Marvel superhero special-effects-laden ensemble will have taken in an estimated $200.3 million before the day is over. Following John Carter, Mars Needs Moms, Cars 2, The Muppets, TRON: Legacy, Secretariat, and other domestic underperformers in the last couple of years, Disney executives must be, to put it mildly, ecstatic.

The previous opening-weekend box office record holder, David Yates / Daniel Radcliffe's Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 2, earned $169.2 million last summer. Both The Avengers and Deathly Hallows 2 have the advantage of box-office-boosting 3D surcharges: 52 percent of The Avengers' gross came from 3D screenings. That surely helped the Joss Whedon-directed actioner to become (as per Box Office Mojo, and not adjusted for inflation) the fastest movie to reach $100m, $150m, and $200m. That is, of course, if studio estimates are correct. We'll find out for sure on Monday.

The Avengers / The Dark Knight box office tossup?

In terms of box office gross, The Avengers has far surpassed the opening-weekend earnings of Christopher Nolan / Christian Bale's The Dark Knight even when taking inflation into account: The Dark Knight would have earned $172-175 million in 2012 dollars, depending on average domestic ticket prices for this second quarter.

However, things get trickier if we try to figure out which movie sold more tickets – the true measure of a film's success – on its first three days out. If 3D surcharges are taken into account (and are thus deducted from the total, say, about 30 percent), The Avengers' box office gross goes down to approximately $175m. When one considers IMAX surcharges as well – The Dark Knight was screened at 94 IMAX theaters vs. The Avengers' 275, which earned $15 million – Nolan's movie quite possibly sold more tickets. Perhaps even Sam Raimi / Tobey Maguire's Spider-Man 3 would be ahead of The Avengers, as its adjusted box office gross would land it at $171-$174m.

All three movies are so close that it's impossible to tell without an actual ticket count whether or not The Avengers is truly the no. 1 opening-weekend movie of all time. The Dark Knight may very well have retained its position at the top. But Hollywood studios refuse to come up with (or to divulge) official figures for ticket sales. Really, how else could studios herald a new record-breaking release every year or so? [See updated article on The Avengers' weekend box office, which far surpassed Sunday estimates.]

Also on the inflation adjusted (but not taking IMAX/3D into account) top-ten opening-weekend box office list are Johnny Depp / Orlando Bloom's Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man's Chest (approx. $164 million), the original Spider-Man ($157 million), Jennifer Lawrence / Liam Hemsworth / Josh Hutcherson's The Hunger Games ($152.5 million), and Kristen Stewart / Robert Pattinson / Taylor Lautner's The Twilight Saga: New Moon ($151 million) and Breaking Dawn Part 1 ($138 million).

Officially budgeted at $220m (not including another $100m+ in marketing / distribution expenses), The Avengers features Captain America: The First Avenger's Chris Evans as Captain America, Sherlock Holmes' Robert Downey Jr as Iron Man, The Kids Are All Right's Mark Ruffalo as the Incredible Hulk, Iron Man 2's Scarlett Johansson as the Black Widow, and Snow White and the Huntsman's Chris Hemsworth as Thor.

Also: The Bourne Legacy's Jeremy Renner as Hawkeye, The Deep Blue Sea's Tom Hiddleston as Loki, The Storm Awaits' Cobie Smulders as Maria Hill, Pulp Fiction's Samuel L. Jackson as Nick Fury, Shakespeare in Love's Gwyneth Paltrow as Pepper Potts, and Much Ado About Nothing's Clark Gregg as agent Phil Coulson.

And finally: Stellan Skarsgård, Powers Boothe, Alexis Denisof, Jenny Agutter, and Deep End director / Roman Polanski's Knife in the Water screenwriter Jerzy Skolimowski, in addition to the voices of Paul Bettany and Lou Ferrigno.

While working on the (eventually) Academy Award-nominated Knife in the Water in Poland in the early '60s, could Jerzy Skolimowski have guessed that half a century later he would be featured in one of the biggest worldwide box office hits ever? Start believing in miracles right now.

Joss Whedon / Chris Hemsworth / The Avengers photo: Zade Rosenthal / Walt Disney Studios.

If you found Box Office: THE AVENGERS / THE DARK KNIGHT Tossup? an informative post, please recommend it to your friends. See share buttons above and on the left.
And consider following Alt Film Guide on Facebook and/or joining the FB group All About Movies.
Box Office: THE AVENGERS / THE DARK KNIGHT Tossup? © 2004-2015 Alt Film Guide and/or author(s). Text NOT to be reproduced without prior written consent.

Continue Reading: Guillermo del Toro: PROMETHEUS Movie Doomed AT THE MOUNTAINS OF MADNESS

Previous Post: New SNOW WHITE AND THE HUNTSMAN Movie Poster

Leave your comment about Box Office: THE AVENGERS / THE DARK KNIGHT Tossup? in the space below. Important: Different views and opinions are perfectly fine, but courtesy and respect are imperative. Abusive, bigoted, baseless, and/or inflammatory comments will be blocked and offenders may be banned.

You can use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

2 Comments to Box Office: THE AVENGERS / THE DARK KNIGHT Tossup?

  1. zac gille


    There are different degrees of "underperforming."

    "John Carter" was a domestic flop, much like "Mars Needs Mom."

    The other three titles you mentioned were indeed underperformers in that they earned less than expected and certainly not enough to get even close to covering their production and distribution / marketing costs (usually about 50% of production budget, though that can vary widely) at the North American box office.

    "The Muppets": $88m dom. gross - studio gets about $45m | reported cost: $45m + est. (at least) $20-$25m marketing/distribution expenses

    "Cars 2": $191m dom gross - studio gets about $100m | reported cost: $200m + est. $100m distribution / marketing expenses

    "TRON: Legacy": $172m dom. gross - studio gets about $90m | reported cost: $170m + est. $85-$90m marketing / distribution expenses.

    See why those are "disappointing" results at the domestic box office?

  2. gopper

    How is 'The Muppets' a domestic underperfomer? The film grossed $90mil domestically on a $45mil budget. 'Tron: Legacy' made $170mil domestically, which was its budget. Although 'Cars 2' didn't break $200mil, it came close with $190mil in the bag. I can't see how these three can be compared to the truly anemic performance of 'John Carter's ($70mil).


CLOVERFIELD Crushes Box-Office Competitors
AVATAR, STAR TREK, 2012 - Oscar 2010 Visual Effects Semi-Finalists
SEX AND THE CITY 2, PRINCE OF PERSIA Underperform; Worst Memorial Day Weekend in Years: Box Office
SHREK FOREVER AFTER Maintains Small Lead; SEX AND THE CITY 2 Highest Average: Box Office
'Eclipse' Breaks Midnight Box Office Record
North American Box Office Passes $10 Billion Mark in 2010: AVATAR Biggest Hit of the Year
Colin Farrell-Peter Weir 'The Way Back' Flops
Bradley Cooper 'Limitless' $100M Worldwide?
Box Office: THE HELP Passes $100m, RISE OF THE PLANET OF THE APES Passes $150m
BREAKING DAWN Unlikely to Reach $300m Domestic
Robert Downey Jr/Guy Ritchie/SHERLOCK HOLMES: A GAME OF SHADOWS Way Behind Original: Box Office
THE DARK KNIGHT RISES Photo: Bane/Brooding, Bulging-Muscled, Scary-Looking Tom Hardy
Christian Bale/THE DARK KNIGHT RISES Photo: Bale As Bruce Wayne
Jennifer Lawrence HOUSE AT THE END OF THE STREET vs. END OF WATCH Box Office
OZ THE GREAT AND POWERFUL Weekend Box Office to Become Best of 2013 by Far
THE LONE RANGER Weekend Box Office: Bigger Flop Than Anticipated?
THOR: THE DARK WORLD Box Office: $100 Million Weekend? Not Likely