We're looking for contributors

Robert Wise/GANGS OF NEW YORK Oscar Ad Aftermath

Robert WiseOscar Campaign Scandal Pt.2: Robert Wise's Oscar Ad a Rebuff to William Goldman's Attack on Martin Scorsese/GANGS OF NEW YORK

Whether or not because of the furor over the Murray Weissman-Robert Wise (photo) ad, despite its ten nominations Martin Scorsese's Gangs of New York failed to win a single Academy Award on Oscar night 2003. But if there was any ill will against Harvey Weinstein and Miramax's heavy-handed Oscar tactics, that certainly didn't prevent another Miramax release, Rob Marshall's musical Chicago, from winning that year's Best Picture Oscar.

Things were different the following year, when Miramax's Anthony Minghella-directed Cold Mountain wasn't shortlisted in the Best Picture category. Whether because of the previous year's flap or because of Nicole Kidman's poor make-up job, that marked the first time in 11 years that a Miramax production wasn't in the running for the Best Picture Oscar – though Cold Mountain did at least earn Renée Zellweger a Best Supporting Actress Oscar, in addition to six other nominations, including Best Actor for Jude Law and Best Cinematography for John Seale. (As per "a source on the film," there was "intense debate involving Anthony and executive producer Harvey Weinstein about digitally smudging Nicole's appearance, roughing up her cheeks, that sort of thing. In the end, time and cost ruled it out. Nicole's appearance dents the credibility of the film and may have cost it Best Picture.")

Following the Robert Wise-Miramax-Gangs of New York firestorm, Academy President Frank Pierson said in a statement that "there will now be personal consequences to improper campaigning." According to the Academy's new rules, "Any Academy member who has authorized, approved or executed a campaign activity that is determined by the Board of Governors to have undermined the letter or spirit of these regulations will be subject to suspension of membership or expulsion from the Academy," while those violations deemed truly serious "could result in a film losing its eligibility for Awards consideration."

Not that such threats have prevented Oscar campaigners from taking "the letter or spirit" of the Academy regulations to the limit – and beyond – with little, if any, consequences, while Academy members continue to campaign for their favorites.

The Hollywood Reporter lists 28 actors – including 11 Oscar winners and 10 Oscar nominees – who participated in this year's edition of Variety's annual "Actors on Actors: SAG Preview." Among those were Julia Roberts praising Viola Davis (The Help); Kate Winslet praising her Mildred Pierce co-star Evan Rachel Wood (The Ides of March); Marion Cotillard on Michelle Williams (My Week with Marilyn); Julianne Moore on Ellen Barkin (Another Happy Day); Anthony Hopkins on his The Silence of the Lambs' co-star Jodie Foster (Carnage); James Franco on Michael Fassbender (Shame); Bette Midler on Glenn Close (Albert Nobbs); and Jane Fonda and Diane Keaton on, respectively, Martha Marcy May Marlene's actresses Elizabeth Olsen and Sarah Paulson.

Now, should there be consequences for endorsements by Academy members used as de facto (or subtle) Oscar campaigns? What about consequences for an Academy member like William Goldman penning or voicing a gratuitous public attack against a nominee?

Feinberg, for one, thinks not – at least when it comes to "positive campaigning." In his THR piece, he asks: "Why shouldn't an Academy member be able to publicly express his or her affection for a film or performance like anyone else can? And why shouldn't a studio be permitted to quote them if they wish to?"

Note: A version of this three-part Miramax/Robert Wise/Gangs of New York article was initially posted in March 2010.

If you found Robert Wise/GANGS OF NEW YORK Oscar Ad Aftermath an informative post, please recommend it to your friends. See share buttons above and on the left.
And consider following Alt Film Guide on Facebook and/or joining the FB group All About Movies.
Robert Wise/GANGS OF NEW YORK Oscar Ad Aftermath © 2004-2015 Alt Film Guide and/or author(s). Text NOT to be reproduced without prior written consent.

Continue Reading: Brad Pitt, Viola Davis, Octavia Spencer

Previous Post: William Goldman Attack Martin Scorsese/GANGS OF NEW YORK

Leave your comment about Robert Wise/GANGS OF NEW YORK Oscar Ad Aftermath in the space below. Important: Different views and opinions are perfectly fine, but courtesy and respect are imperative. Abusive, bigoted, baseless, and/or inflammatory comments will be blocked and offenders may be banned.

You can use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

1 Comment to Robert Wise/GANGS OF NEW YORK Oscar Ad Aftermath

  1. For years I have worked on a true story about a man who was from the time period of Gangs of New York...So popular and admired people named their children, towns, streets and schools after him...yet not a word about him was written in the dialog of Gangs of NY...Then there was the film Martin produced using the man's home as a setting where Michelle P was the lead --again - not a word mentioned about him. I wish I had the talent (writers, actors, producers and money) has Martin has access too- but I do not...I was able to work with a top DP from Hollywood who on his death bed made me promise to continue to push for this film because he believed the story is so powerful - that it would easily be an Oscar contender...As the writer - I would hand my script over to either Martin or Robert...because I know both have the talent and influence to produce pictures audiences will enjoy. Oscar or not - audiences worldwide enjoy their work....Only disappointment I see every year is Leonardo being passed over...If anyone deserves it - he does.


HALF NELSON Review - Ryan Gosling, Shareeka Epps Ryan Fleck
Oscar 2007: "Shorts!" in New York City
Oscar 2009: Best Foreign-Language Film Submissions
Oscar 2010: Ten Best Picture Nominees
Oscar 2009 Predictions: Best Documentary, Animated Film
George Lucas, Meg Tilly, Kirk Douglas: Governors Awards 2009
Oscar 2010 Predictions: Best Cinematography, Original Score, Original Song, etc.
Maggie Gyllenhaal, Vera Farmiga: Oscar Nominees Luncheon Photo
THE HURT LOCKER's Oscar No-No: Producer Nicolas Chartier's Vote-Soliciting E-mail
Fred Astaire-Ginger Rogers' SWING TIME Academy Screening
Oscar 2011 Best Foreign Language Film Academy Screenings: TIRZA, SIMPLE SIMON, STEAM OF LIFE, ANGEL
Jacki Weaver Oscar Red Carpet 2011: Photo
The Oscar 2011 Hostess the Academy Needed
Natalie Portman Would Have Won Best Actress Oscar Regardless: BLACK SWAN Dance Double Controversy
Eddie Murphy No Longer Oscar 2012 Host
2012 Oscar Predictions Best Actor: George Clooney, Jean Dujardin, Brad Pitt
2012 Oscar Predictions Best Director: Woody Allen, Martin Scorsese, Michel Hazanavicius
Albert Brooks Oscar Snub Irks Russell Crowe, Adolf Hitler
PGA Awards 2013 vs. Academy Awards 2013
ALONE YET NOT ALONE: Best Song Oscar Nomination Revoked