We're looking for contributors

Shirley Jones: From Book to Movies

Shirley Jones BookShirley Jones: From book to film

A few weeks ago, Shirley Jones, 79, made headlines following the publication of her book of memoirs, concisely titled Shirley Jones: A Memoir. But why the headlines? Does Shirley Jones twerk like Miley Cyrus? Nope. (And that may explain why the release of Jones' book wasn't selected as CNN.com's Top Story of the Day.) So, were The Media and The People interested in Jones' Best Supporting Actress Academy Award for Elmer Gantry, or maybe they were curious about her work in several major 1950s musicals and 1960s comedies? Are you crazy? Who gives a damn about that? The Answer: Let's just say that the furor had something to do with sweet and innocent all-American bare breasts and three-ways. Keep that in mind next time you watch Oklahoma! (Photo: Shirley Jones ca. 1955.) (On TCM: "Shirley Jones Movies: Innocent Virgins and Sex Workers Galore.")

Anyhow, those who've read The Shirley Jones Book can now watch The Shirley Jones Movies. Perhaps it's only a coincidence that Jones, best remembered as the matriarch in the TV series The Partridge Family, is one of the featured stars in Turner Classic Movies' "Summer Under the Stars" series this August 2013. Or perhaps it's some sort of pre-planned tie-in: buy The Memoir, watch The Music Man. Either way, August 28 is Shirley Jones Day on TCM.

Shirley Jones: Oscar winner for 'Elmer Gantry'

Right now, TCM is showing writer-director Richard Brooks' Elmer Gantry (1960), based on the first half of Sinclair Lewis' novel about religion and its not infrequent connection to human nastiness, madness, and imbecility. So much so, in fact, that at the time of the book's publication in the late '20s Lewis was berated by assorted Christian leaders, with Evangelical pastor Billy Sunday calling him "Satan's cohort." With that sort of publicity, Elmer Gantry inevitably became a top bestseller. If only Brooks' movie had been that lucky.

The key problem is that whereas Sinclair Lewis' novel is daring and combative, Elmer Gantry the movie is mostly quite tame. Even so, the film has several points of interest; chief among these are its two leading ladies: Jean Simmons as the gentler, kinder Aimee Semple McPherson-ish Sister Sharon Falconer and Shirley Jones as the gorgeous sex worker who, after getting the Fear of God rammed deep into her, brings down Evangelical preacher Elmer Gantry -- played by Burt Lancaster with lots of gusto and lots of teeth.

Another positive point for Elmer Gantry: it's infinitely more gripping and more complex than Robert Duvall's The Apostle, made nearly four decades later.

Shirley Jones: Lovely Leading Lady (with little to do)

Next comes the romantic comedy The Courtship of Eddie's Father (1963), featuring future Oscar-winning director Ron Howard (A Beautiful Mind) as a little brat who wants to hook his Dad up with a Cool Chick. Directed by Vincente Minnelli, The Courtship of Eddie's Father shares several key plot points with dozens of movies, from Deanna Durbin's Three Smart Girls and Jane Powell's Three Daring Daughters to the Lindsay Lohan version of The Parent Trap and Nora Ephron's Sleepless in Seattle -- with Glenn Ford as Tom Hanks and Shirley Jones as Meg Ryan. (Speaking of Sleepless in Seattle, Nora Ephron's direction to Meg Ryan wouldn't have worked had Ryan checked out Shirley Jones' book of memoirs, which sounds like proof positive that not all Republicans are sexually repressed.)

Directed by Broadway's Morton DaCosta (Auntie Mame), The Music Man (1962) is only for inveterate fans of the musical, as the movie version plods along seemingly forever. Robert Preston, who originated the role onstage, bursts with energy in the title role, but he's clearly playing to the last seat in the last row in the last gallery. A major miscalculation for which DaCosta was equally responsible.

Though not exactly an instant classic, The Music Man was a major box office hit and earned a Best Picture Academy Award nomination. Back in the '60s, such top-level Academy recognition was not uncommon for big-budget studio movies, whether or not they had been well received upon their release. Other examples include West Side Story, How the West Was Won, Cleopatra, Mutiny on the Bounty, The Sound of Music, My Fair Lady, Doctor Dolittle, The Longest Day, Anne of the Thousand Days, and Hello, Dolly!. As for Shirley Jones, she looks lovely in The Music Man.

Though not directed by Morton DaCosta, Carousel (1956) feels just as stagy as The Music Man. It's curious that Henry King, a movie veteran with more than three decades behind the camera, would fall prey to the theatricality of the stage show. Considerably less effervescent -- or rather, less overbearing -- than The Music Man's Robert Preston, Carousel's Gordon MacRae is a much more pleasant screen presence. As for Shirley Jones, she looks lovely in Carousel.

Shirley Jones, Richard Brooks, and Jean Simmons together again: 'The Happy Ending'

Writer-director Richard Brooks, Jean Simmons, and Shirley Jones joined forces once again in The Happy Ending (1969), a psychological drama about a middle-aged married woman with alcohol and drug problems, who takes off on her own on the day of her 16th wedding anniversary. Sounds good? Unfortunately, it isn't. Jean Simmons could be an outstanding actress, but in The Happy Ending her performance -- nominated for a Best Actress Oscar -- feels a tad calculated. Perhaps it hit too close to home: Simmons did eventually develop an alcohol problem during her marriage (1960-1977) to Richard Brooks.

Compounding matters, The Happy Ending veers into Higher Morals territory every now and then. For instance, a sequence featuring sex worker Bobby Darin talking about "preserving his juices" or some such is simply cringeworthy. As for Shirley Jones, she looks lovely in The Happy Ending -- and is wasted in a Best Friend role that promises much more than it delivers. Equally wasted is veteran Teresa Wright as Simmons' concerned mother.

You want a good movie about a Middle-Aged Married Woman and Mom Finding Herself? Then check out Herbert Brenon's Dancing Mothers, starring Alice Joyce. Now, that is a drama with a "modern" feel. Released in 1926 -- more than four decades before The Happy Ending.

["From Book to Movies: Memoirist Shirley Jones" continues on the next page. See link below.]

If you enjoyed reading Shirley Jones: From Book to Movies and/or found it an informative post, please recommend it to your friends. See share buttons above or on the left.
Shirley Jones: From Book to Movies last modified:

Continue Reading: Shirley Jones Movies: Innocent Virgins and Sex Workers Galore

Previous Post: Martin Balsam: Oscar Winner Supports Joanne Woodward, Charles Bronson


"Shirley Jones: From Book to Movies" © 2004-2014 Alt Film Guide and/or author(s). Text NOT to be reproduced without prior written consent.


Feel free to leave your comment about the Alt Film Guide article "Shirley Jones: From Book to Movies" in the space below. Note: Different views and opinions are perfectly fine, but courtesy and respect are imperative. Abusive, bigoted, trollish, baseless (spreading rumors or misinformation), and inflammatory comments and/or remarks will be deleted, and such commenters may be banned.

You can use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>




PERSONA and BEING JOHN MALKOVICH: Movies on the Mind Screenings
PORGY AND BESS 1959 Movie: Rare Samuel Goldwyn Production Gets New York Screening
Errol Flynn THE ADVENTURES OF ROBIN HOOD Screening
MADE IN U.S.A / 2 OR 3 THINGS I KNOW ABOUT HER Review: Anna Karina Jean-Luc Godard
TCM Classic Film Festival: A STAR IS BORN, METROPOLIS, BREATHLESS, 2001
CAVALCADE Review - Clive Brook, Diana Wynyard Frank Lloyd
GONE WITH THE WIND vs. MELODY RANCH: The Unreliability of Box Office Polls
Ann Dvorak Pt.3: SCARFACE, Warner Bros. Leading Lady, But Never a Star
Oscar-Nominated IMITATION OF LIFE Actress Juanita Moore Dies on New Year's Day 2014
Maximilian Schell Director: Maria Schell, Marlene Dietrich