SLEUTH at Venice 2007: To Remake or Not to Remake
September 5th, 2007 by Andre Soares
Agnès Poirier in The Guardian:
"It wasn’t quite as bad as the screening of Christopher Hampton’s Imagining Argentina, which, in 2003, had the Venice Film Festival audience laughing hysterically when it should have been crying. However, the screening of Sleuth, directed by Kenneth Branagh, must have provoked embarrassment for its producers when it left both public and critics sneering. Despite what Martin Wainwright writes in The Guardian today, the feeling, at least among European film critics, was of huge disappointment if not scorn: why on earth remake a masterpiece by [Joseph L.] Mankiewicz, which already was a big screen remake of an award-winning theatre play by Anthony Shaffer?"
Personally, I believe there are some good reasons for remaking films as the same story can take on different angles and interpretations. Think of how many Romeo and Juliet film adaptations have been made in the last century, from straightforward retellings of Shakespeare’s play to West Side Story – about xenophobia, racism, and balletic gangbangers in New York City — and, more recently, The Bubble, in which a Jewish man and Palestinian man must face anti-gay bigotry in addition to the usual Jewish-Palestinian prejudices.
Another case in point: Poirier pooh-poohs Philip Noyce’s 2001 remake of another Joseph L. Mankiewicz drama, The Quiet American. I haven’t seen the original, but I found the remake a well-crafted, intelligent, beautifully acted, and quite timely film.
The new Sleuth, written by Harold Pinter, is supposed to be radically different from the 1972 original, which starred Michael Caine and Laurence Olivier.
Venice Film Festival Awards - 2007
64th Venice Film Festival: Competition Line-Up
64th Venice Film Festival: Out of Competition Line-Up
Venice Film Festival 2007 - Horizons Sidebar
LUST, CAUTION Controversy at Venice Film Festival 2007
Venice Film Festival 2007 - The British Have Arrived
Queer Lion for Gay-Themed Films at the Venice Film Festival
A Golden Lion for Peter Greenaway?
Woody Allen’s CASSANDRA’S DREAM at the Venice Film Festival 2007
I’M NOT THERE: Bob Dylan Not at the Venice Film Festival 2007
THE GRAIN OF LIFE: Great Cinema at Venice 2007
Top Contenders for the Venice Film Festival 2007 Awards
Leave a Reply
Note: All comments are moderated, and may be edited at the discretion of the moderator. Different views and opinions are welcome, but abusive/bigoted remarks, and both flaming and generic (spam) comments will NOT be approved. Also, please be aware that the Alternative Film Guide has NO contact information for the talent mentioned in this blog or any information pertaining to or access to distributors'/producers' film prints.
