***We're looking for contributors***


'The Hurt Locker' Oscar Controversy: Producer Nicolas Chartier Vote-Soliciting Email

Feb. 27 update

Anthony Mackie, Jeremy Renner in The Hurt Locker
Anthony Mackie, Jeremy Renner in The Hurt Locker

The Hurt Locker producer Nicolas Chartier will be facing some sort of punishment from the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences following multiple e-mails he sent out asking Academy members to vote for the Kathryn Bigelow-directed Iraq War drama and not an unnamed “$500 million film” widely known as Avatar as the Best Picture of 2009. The Academy will refrain from announcing the penalty until after the voting deadline ends next Tuesday.

According to an Associated Press report, Chartier's initial e-mail was sent Feb. 19. He later followed suit with other e-mails giving more detailed instructions on how Academy voters should fill in their Best Picture ballots, with The Hurt Locker on top and Avatar at the bottom of the list.

The Hurt Locker distributor Summit Pictures declared in a statement that it was “completely unaware of any e-mails that were sent until we were alerted by the academy earlier this week,” while the film's screenwriter Mark Boal told the Los Angeles Times blog 24 Frames, “I knew nothing about it, I think it's incredibly stupid and wrong and I hope he stops.”

Chartier later issued a mea culpa, but that may have been a little too late. As mentioned before at Alt Film Guide and elsewhere, in all likelihood nothing will happen to The Hurt Locker. It'll remain in the running. Chartier may lose his tickets for the Oscar ceremony, but that may well be about it – unless the Academy decides not to invite him to join their ranks later in the year.

Ironically, Chartier had to fight to be included among the film's nominated producers – Boal, Bigelow, and Greg Shapiro are the others – as Academy rules prevent a Best Picture nominee from having more than three producers in the Oscar race except under extraordinary circumstances. According to various reports, Chartier put up most of the financing for The Hurt Locker.

20th Century Fox, James Cameron, and others involved the making and distribution of Avatar have thus far kept mum about the issue.

Photo: The Hurt Locker (Jonathan Olley / Summit Entertainment)

Jeremy Renner in The Hurt Locker
Jeremy Renner in The Hurt Locker

Remember the backlash following former Academy president and two-time Best Director Oscar winner Robert Wise's ad asking Academy members to vote for Martin Scorsese's Miramax release Gangs of New York back in early 2003? You don't? Well, apparently neither does Voltage Pictures producer Nicolas Chartier, whose The Hurt Locker is the favorite to win this year's Best Picture Academy Award after bagging the BAFTA for Best Picture, Best Director, and Best Original Screenplay, and top awards from the Producers Guild, the Directors Guild, and the Writers Guild. [See Robert Wise/Gangs of New York addendum below.]

Chartier, who is one of the Iraq War drama's Oscar-nominated producers along with Greg Shapiro, director Kathryn Bigelow, and journalist-turned-screenwriter Mark Boal, sent an e-mail to some Academy members asking for their vote while taking a direct swipe at his film's chief competitor, the blockbuster Avatar, directed, written, and co-produced by Bigelow's former husband James Cameron.

Here's Chartier's e-mail, as posted by Pete Hammond in the Los Angeles Times blog Notes on a Season:

I hope all is well with you. I just wanted to write you and say I hope you liked Hurt Locker and if you did and want us to win, please tell (name deleted) and your friends who vote for the Oscars, tell actors, directors, crew members, art directors, special effects people, if everyone tells one or two of their friends, we will win and not a $500M film, we need independent movies to win like the movies you and I do, so if you believe The Hurt Locker is the best movie of 2010 [sic], help us!

I'm sure you know plenty of people you've worked with who are academy members whethere [sic] a publicist, a writer, a sound engineer, please take 5 minutes and contact them. Please call one or two persons, everything will help!

best regards,

Nicolas Chartier Voltage Pictures

Note: Fox insists Avatar cost about $200 million, though some reports claim the 3D sci-fi adventure did cost as much as $500 million. To date, according to Box Office Mojo Avatar has taken in $690 million domestically and $1.755 billion internationally for a grand total of $2.465 billion. The Hurt Locker cost $15 million; it grossed $12.6 million at the North American box office and $5.9 million overseas for a total of $18.5 million. In other words, The Hurt Locker grossed less than 1 percent of Avatar's worldwide take – and Avatar is still doing great business.

Chartier has since apologized by way of another e-mail, in which he takes full responsibility for the vote-soliciting e-mail (implying he didn't consult with anyone else), as posted on Tom O'Neil's Gold Derby:

Last week  I emailed  you regarding the Oscars next week, generally, and “The Hurt Locker,” in particular.

My email to you was out of line and not in the spirit of the celebration of cinema that this acknowledgement is. I was even more wrong, both personally and professionally, to ask for your help in encouraging others to vote for the film and to comment on another movie. As  passionate as I am about the film  we made, this was an extremely inappropriate email to send, and something that the Academy strongly disapproves of in the rules.

My naivete, ignorance of the rules and plain stupidity as a first time nominee  is not an excuse for this behavior and I strongly regret it. Being nominated for an Academy Award is the ultimate honor and I should have taken the time to read the rules.

I am emailing  each person this very same statement asking  to retract my previous email and requesting that you please disregard it.

I truly apologize to anyone I have offended.

Sincerely yours,

best regards, Nicolas Chartier Voltage Pictures, LLC

Here's the Academy rule regarding e-mail solicitations at Oscar time (curiously, I couldn't find an item on that page specifically pertaining to direct mailings):

E-mail that is sent to Academy members must adhere to the same regulations concerning content and appearance as direct mailings that are delivered by the post office or via other delivery methods. It may not extol the merits of a film, an achievement or an individual. It may not contain quotes from reviews about a film or an achievement, nor should it refer to other honors or awards, past or present, that have been received by either the film or those involved in the production or distribution of the film. Except as permitted in Regulation #5, e-mail to members may not include mention of, or links to, any Web site that promotes any eligible film.

Here's another Academy rule broken by Chartier's e-mail:

Ads, mailings, Web sites or any other forms of communication that attempt to promote a particular film or achievement by casting a negative or derogatory light on a competing film or achievement are not permitted. In particular, any tactic that singles out “the competition” by name or title is expressly forbidden.

What if Chartier had called Academy members instead of e-mailing them? That would have been even worse.

Contacting Academy members by telephone to promote a film or achievement is expressly forbidden, even if such contact is in the guise of checking to make sure a screener was received. Telephone calls to verify members' addresses are permitted, as long as no eligible films are discussed.

What kind of “punishment,” if any, Chartier will get remains unclear. The Hurt Locker will not be disqualified. That's a given. But the producer may have to give up on his Oscar night tickets. Or he may not. In any case, The Hurt Locker is considered the top contender for the Best Picture Academy Award and it's a lock for the Best Director Oscar. Here's wondering why Chartier would find it necessary to resort to such a desperate-sounding vote-soliciting e-mail.

By the way, Gangs of New York ended up getting zero Oscars despite its 10 nominations. Don't expect the same to happen to The Hurt Locker.

The Oscar 2010 drama will unfold on Sunday, March 7.

Addendum: Chartier's vote-soliciting e-mail is absolutely nothing compared to what the people behind Gangs of New York did seven years ago. After all, Robert Wise was a former Academy president whose newspaper ad turned out to be have been written by publicist Murray Weissman, then working for Miramax's Oscar campaign.

Photo: The Hurt Locker (Jonathan Olley / Summit Entertainment)

If you liked the article 'The Hurt Locker' Oscar Controversy: Producer Nicolas Chartier Vote-Soliciting Email, please recommend it to your friends and/or follow Alt Film Guide on social media. See share/follow buttons above.
'The Hurt Locker' Oscar Controversy: Producer Nicolas Chartier Vote-Soliciting Email © 2004–2017 Alt Film Guide and/or author(s).
Text NOT to be reproduced without prior written consent.

Leave a comment about ''The Hurt Locker' Oscar Controversy: Producer Nicolas Chartier Vote-Soliciting Email'

UPDATED COMMENTING RULES: Our articles and/or other people's comments infuriate you?

Well, here's the good news: It's perfectly okay to disagree with our own and/or other commenters' views and opinions.

But ... *thoughtfulness* and *at least a modicum of sanity* are imperative.

In other words: Add something reasonable & coherent to the discussion.

Spammy, abusive, bigoted, baseless (spreading misinformation), trollish/inflammatory, and/or just plain demented comments will be zapped and offenders may be banned.

Also, bear in mind that links found in comments will generally be deleted.

Most recent comments listed on top.

5 Comments to 'The Hurt Locker' Oscar Controversy: Producer Nicolas Chartier Vote-Soliciting Email

  1. Oliver

    If you read the reviews on imdb.com, you'll see film lovers and military personnel have been criticizing The Hurt Locker since it came out! As a war film fan, I thought it was much like the average Hollywood studio pic, a weak plot cemented together with lots of explosions. The result? I was bored to pieces! The fact that it's awards season and that a slightly better than average indie pic is winning so many is what has people riled up. I couldn't understand it until now, I bet this e-mail is just the tip of the iceberg that sunk the Titanic, I mean Avatar! LOL!
    PS He said he didn't know the rules but made it a point not to mention Avatar by name or title, yet clearly referenced it? Taking away his extra tickets for the Oscars so he and his friends can't watch Hurt Locker collect all the awards in person is no punishment at all! LOL! If the Academy doesn't disqualify the pic, the Academy Awards will become a joke. Unless of course, they already have!

  2. K.R.

    Avatar fans are salivating over this story which is hilarious because they've been threatened by The Hurt Locker ever since it started winning several awards this season. The criticisms coming from Military personnel is like kids crying in the sandbox, it's a movie, get over it. Make your own movies if you think you can do it better.

    Anyway, this story is a nonissue for me. We can all agree that Chartier was an idiot for sending the emails. Like no other studios or producers have done the same thing before only this time N.C. got caught by a tattletale. Now all the Academy has to do is remove Chartier's producing credit for the film, take his tickets away and be done with him. It's that simple. Move on.

  3. Alex

    Nobody made remarks because hardly anyone knew about the movie before. I didn't even hear about The Hurt Locker until January.

  4. Ned

    Suddenly THE HURT LOCKER is being attacked on different fronts. Some veterans now say the film is wildly inaccurate and then Nicolas Chartier's email is leaked to the media.
    THE HURT LOCKER was out months ago. Why didn't anyone remark on its inaccuracies then?

  5. Cynthia

    The guy wrote an e-mail asking for votes. What's the big deal? It's spam I guess but if he's friends with the people he wrote asking for votes then it should be ok.