Home Movie Reviews Godzilla 1954 (Gojira) Movie Review: One of Cinema’s Greatest Monsters Ever

Godzilla 1954 (Gojira) Movie Review: One of Cinema’s Greatest Monsters Ever

Godzilla 1954. Whether in Ishirô Honda’s Japanese original Gojira or in the 1956 U.S. version, Godzilla, King of the Monsters!, the gigantic – and gigantically destructive – reptilian creature remains one of cinema’s iconic creations.
  • Godzilla (1954) movie review: As the cinematic symbol of our potentially apocalyptic atomic age, the awesomely destructive creature seen in Ishirô Honda’s horror classic remains one of the most exemplary big-screen monsters ever.
  • Godzilla 1954 vs. the 1956 U.S. version: Which is the superior movie?

Godzilla 1954 movie review: Gojira is cinema’s ‘King of the Monsters’ in iconic Japanese horror classic & 1956 U.S. version

Heaven. When I came across the long-awaited DVD release of the original Godzilla 1954 a.k.a. Gojira, I thought I had struck heaven. That it was accompanied by its Americanized cousin, Godzilla, King of the Monsters! (1956), only doubled the joy of expectation. For once, I was not disappointed.

The mark of a good critic is admitting biases, so I will state up front that as a young boy, growing up in the late 1960s and early 1970s, I used to watch the annual American release of the latest Godzilla film at the old Ridgewood Theater. That was one of the few joys to be had in the depressing urban blight of Queens; so, objectivity will not be feigned in this essay.

The best of that sillier run of films was Godzilla’s Revenge, in which the titular character took on a mythical stature in the mind of a lonely latchkey child who kept bullies and gangsters at bay while communing with Godzilla’s son, Minya.

Yet nothing could top Godzilla, King of the Monsters!, with Raymond Burr – old Perry Mason and Ironside himself – as reporter Steve Martin. I must have seen that film on TV for the first time when I was four or five, and damn, it was scary. Other than its quickie sequel, Godzilla Raids Again (1955), none of the 1960s and 1970s Godzilla movies ever portrayed the beast as such pure hellish destruction.

Even in youth I could discern that the original was easily the best and that it was more than truly scary: It was scratching at that unnamed part in all developing minds. It had things to offer I could not quite place at that time.

Stronger appreciation

I’d always heard that my favorite movie was derived from an original Japanese production that didn’t have the Raymond Burr intercuts. Having become an expert in every Godzilla film, from the 1956 American version to Godzilla 1985, I was always excited by the prospect of some day seeing the Japanese original. I’d even watched a handful of the post-1985 movies, but the original remained a mystery.

Finally, in 2004 Rialto Pictures released Godzilla 1954 across American theaters for its 50th anniversary. And earlier this year, Classic Media released the Toho Film production and its American version as a two-disc DVD, so that a side-by-side comparison could be made.

After watching both films, with and without the commentaries, my appreciation for Gojira – directed by Ishirô Honda, and written by Honda and Takeo Murata, from Shigeru Kayama’s “story” – as well as for the U.S. version, often derided as a bastardization, has grown stronger.

Neither one can really be considered a great “film” – but great movies? Hell, yes! The difference between the two labels is the difference between a great novel and a great comic book: Great films really move one to think more deeply about life, whereas a great movie does that a bit, perhaps, but more often it greatly entertains.

Both Godzilla 1954 and King of the Monsters! easily qualify on that score. In addition, with their anti-atomic messages and unflinching look at destruction, they are better than Merian C. Cooper and Ernest B. Schoedsack’s original King Kong (1933) – which is still a great movie itself.

Godzilla 1954 vs. King Kong & The Beast from 20,000 Fathoms

In spite of the rubber-suited reptilian scoffed at by stop-motion enthusiasts, what raises Godzilla – especially Gojira – above King Kong, is that the Japanese monster tale still has resonance today. It can thus be seen as an allegory, whereas King Kong is essentially just a ripping good yarn.

Yes, Godzilla 1954, reportedly the most expensive Japanese production up to that time, owes a great debt to King Kong, whose 1952 rerelease was a remarkable hit. And in truth, it owes an even greater one to the success of Eugène Lourié’s 1953 monster movie The Beast from 20,000 Fathoms (based on Ray Bradbury’s short story “The Fog Horn”).

Having said that, Godzilla has a political resonance and emotional depth that both King Kong and The Beast from 20,000 Fathoms lack. After all, Kong is basically a victim while the Beast (a Rhedosaurus) is just a hungry lizard.

Godzilla, on the other hand, was a by-product of the atomic age, even if, cleverly, Honda covered his ass by never explicitly showing this to be true. In fact, the monster’s motives are never made clear, as it does not seem to be seeking food.

So, is it nature’s revenge on humanity or a cosmic random bit of fury?

Godzilla, King of the Monsters! with Raymond Burr. In the eastern half of the U.S. , the Americanized version of Godzilla 1954 was distributed by Embassy Pictures – later of The Graduate & The Lion in Winter fame. TransWorld Releasing handled the western half of the country.

Godzilla 1954 vs. King of the Monsters!

The plot of Godzilla, King of the Monsters! is well known: An American reporter, Steve Martin (Raymond Burr), tells the story in flashback, after Godzilla has leveled Tokyo, leaving him recovering in a hospital. He is reputedly pals with a brilliant scientist named Dr. Daisuke Serizawa (Akihiko Hirata), although the two never seem to meet up.

Acting as an impassive observer, Martin turns up at key moments in the film until he, along with thousands of others, ends up being nearly killed by the beast. Eventually, he recovers and witnesses Serizawa descend to the depths of Tokyo Bay to destroy Godzilla with a weapon as powerful as the atom bomb: The Oxygen Destroyer.

Godzilla 1954 is a bit different; obviously there’s no Raymond Burr character and the film itself is longer, at 98 minutes vs. 80 for King of the Monsters!. The original opens with a scene of a fishing ship consumed by glowing, boiling water – something that resonated with the Japanese public, as earlier that year a fishing ship caused an international stir after accidentally sailing too close to an American H bomb test in the Pacific.

Comparing Gojira to the shorter American version, much of what was cut out featured references to the atomic bombs dropped on Japan, arguments between politicians over Godzilla, references to the atomic bombs at Hiroshima and Nagasaki, and other scenes that fleshed out the main Japanese characters who were relegated to lesser roles in the U.S. release.

But despite accusations that most of these scenes were cut from Godzilla, King of the Monsters! to downplay anti-Americanism, that is simply not the case.

Anti-American monster movie?

By 1956, when the U.S. version debuted, World War II was long gone and the Japanese were now our friends against the Red Menace. Thus, the idea that the low-budget filmmakers who added the Burr scenes were censoring a political message is a bit far-fetched, especially considering that the dangers of atomic testing and radiation fallout from the monster figure prominently in both versions.

The reasons for the cuts are more easily explained if one imagines what would have happened had Roger Corman gotten a hold of – and re-edited – Nosferatu, Metropolis, Invasion of the Body Snatchers, or even The Birth of a Nation. Major political and sexual themes would have been lost, but this would be attributable to a lack of artistry, not to Corman’s political or sexual views.

On top of that, Godzilla 1954 is explicitly anti-war and anti-atomic bomb, not anti-American. When discussing nuclear technology and its consequences, mankind in general – not any specific nation – is always referred to as the cause. This is a central point many critics have missed.

Moreover, in the Godzilla, King of the Monsters! DVD commentary, director Terry Morse’s son, Terry Morse Jr., debunks the notion that either his father or the film’s U.S. producer, Joseph E. Levine, ever set out to mute political messages.

Godzilla 1954 with Akihiko Hirata, Momoko Kôchi, and Akira Takarada. Tokyo-born Momoko Kôchi (1932–1998) was seen in more than 30 features over the course of four decades. She would reprise her Gojira role in the 1995 sequel Godzilla vs. Destoroyah, her final film.

What’s an actor like you doing in a movie like this?

Politics aside, Godzilla 1954 can also be seen as a representation of the changing postwar Japanese culture, right alongside the great later films of Yasujiro Ozu, in which there are always young Japanese challenging seemingly silly social traditions.

For instance, the youthful female lead in Gojira, Emiko (Momoko Kôchi), dares to turn down her arranged husband-to-be. Although in love with oceanographer/diver Hideto Ogata (Akira Takarada), Emiko has been betrothed to Akihiko Hirata’s eyepatch-wearing Dr. Serizawa, who, on first blush, seems to be the archetypal mad scientist working alone on a top-secret project.

As a plus, Godzilla features the great Takashi Shimura, just off of his excellent roles in Akira Kurosawa’s Ikiru and Seven Samurai. Shimura plays Dr. Kyouhei Yamane, Emiko’s father and a paleontologist who becomes the film’s resident monster expert, naturally fearing that destroying the creature will be a great loss to science. The presence of a veteran of many Kurosawa films in something like this is akin to Gary Cooper or Cary Grant getting cast in a Frankenstein movie.

Of course, Dr. Yamane gets his geology totally wrong, stating that the Jurassic Period was only two million years ago (the Jurassic ended 130 million years ago) and that the Age of Dinosaurs ended with it (the last dinosaurs died out 65 million years ago at the end of the Cretaceous Period). That said, along with the often ridiculed dubbing, Godzilla films are recalled with affection for their bad science.

Which is the better Godzilla movie?

While it cuts key scenes from Godzilla 1954, the U.S. version amply compensates by not having the ending of one of its major characters as manifestly foreshadowed as in the original. These sorts of wise screenplay and directing choices keep the American film not too far behind the Japanese original in overall artistic quality.

Besides, the fact that the U.S. version, told from an unnamed future, plays out from Steve Martin’s perspective should naturally allow for the condensation of many of the Japanese scenes because the American reporter sums up the plot points brought out by the other characters. Else, Godzilla, King of the Monsters! would have dragged on too long.

Another usually ignored plus is that there is a subliminal dissonance between what we see – i.e., the cinéma vérité newsreel-like images – and the fact that Martin tells the whole tale in flashback, magically appearing at all the right moments.

That dissonance provides King of the Monsters! with a dreamy quality that the original lacks, something reinforced by the fact that Martin never really interacts with the main Japanese characters despite some quite skilled intercutting. In fact, he seems to exist outside the film. It’s akin to having a lucid dream – that feeling that nothing can happen to the main character … you.

Oddly, this dreamy narrative is part of a documentary-like approach, a schism that affects the viewer in ways not noticeable the first time around, though the feeling lingers afterward. I’ve never known anyone who watched Godzilla, King of the Monsters! and was not affected by it, whether positively or negatively.

Godzilla 1954 stars the reptilian monster as an overgrown child of the atomic age. In the last half-century, Ishirô Honda’s horror classic has led to about 30 sequels, remakes, and re-edits. In fact, Godzilla is officially recognized as the longest-running movie franchise ever.

‘Preternatural beast’

Now, a positive in both black-and-white films is that much of Godzilla’s destruction takes place at night – as this heightens what the viewer can imbue. The imagined is always more frightening than the real.

This also goes for the monster itself, as in the cross-cuts from rubber-suited man to miniatures, matte paintings, and puppets, the creature seems to be a shapeshifter, a preternatural beast – e.g., there are times we see pupils in Godzilla’s eyes and times when the monster seems like a white-eyed zombie or demon.

A few years later, the great British horror movie Night of the Demon (1957), directed by the inimitable Jacques Tourneur, would similarly make use of darkness to give its monster a shapeshifting feel, as well as hide its flaws in construction. (Perhaps as some sort of cosmic coincidence, Tourneur’s film was also released in an American version, Curse of the Demon, that has been ripped as a bastardization.)

Skillful behind-the-scenes talent

Also worth noting is that whereas later films gave Godzilla a traditional dragon’s fire breath, the original beast spews atomic radiation in a mist that ignites fires – showing that the roots of Godzilla were not in Japanese lore but in modern monster mythos.

All of these effects were skillfully created by Eiji Tsuburaya, and despite the ridicule that subsequent Godzilla films have engendered, the original had better effects and was more cleverly shot – to downplay its shortcomings – than other monster movies of its era.

Just as impressive is Akira Ifukube’s score. The opening footfalls of the monster are still as scary as any nightmare, while the main Godzilla theme, as well as those in other scenes, still resonate because they are fully apropos.

I don’t know who was responsible for Godzilla’s trademark roar, but it’s equally memorable.

Great ‘movies’

Unlike in most other monster movies, the heroes in both Godzilla 1954 and King of the Monsters! are fallible little mortals whose heroism comes from their choices, not their strength or superhuman powers. That is especially true in the Japanese original, in which the de facto lead character – like the creature’s size and appearance – seems to shift throughout the film.

This is what humanizes these two Godzilla movies – not films – and makes them affect a viewer willing to suspend disbelief. After all, is a rampaging, giant atomic reptile really any more unbelievable than bloodsucking vampires, a huge ape who lusts after a woman one-twentieth its size, or aliens who grow out of pods?

Once again, neither Gojira nor its U.S. version is a great film. But they are great movies – something that is a rarity – in addition to being two of the best monster movies ever made.

Classic Media’s recent DVD set should finally debunk claims to the contrary, thus allowing Godzillaphiles to come out of the closet to proudly proclaim who they are. I am one. Long live the roar!

Godzilla / Gojira (1954) cast & crew

Director: Ishirô Honda.

Screenplay: Ishirô Honda & Takeo Murata.
From a treatment by Shigeru Kayama, itself based on an outline titled “The Giant Monster from 20,000 Leagues Under the Sea,” written by Godzilla 1954 producer Tomoyuki Tanaka.

Cast: Akira Takarada. Momoko Kôchi. Takashi Shimura. Akihiko Hirata. Fuyuki Murakami. Sachio Sakai. Ren Yamamoto. Toyoaki Suzuki.

Cinematography: Masao Tamai. Film Editing: Kazuji Taira (as Taichin Taira). Music: Akira Ifukube. Production Design: Satoru Chûko & Takeo Kita. Producer: Tomoyuki Tanaka.

Runtime: 96 min.

Country: Japan.

Related Films: The Beast from 20,000 Fathoms (1953). The Host (2006). It Came from Beneath the Sea (1955). Jaws (1975). King Kong (1933, 1976, 2005). The Lost World (1925, 1960). The Lost World: Jurassic Park (1993). Mothra (1961). Pacific Rim (2013). Them! (1954). 20 Million Miles to Earth (1957). The War of the Worlds (1953, 2005).


Godzilla, King of the Monsters! (1956)

U.S. version of Gojira, with additional footage directed by Terry Morse and featuring Raymond Burr. Besides, some footage from Godzilla 1954 was cut from the American version.

Runtime: 80 min.

Country: Japan | United States.

Godzilla 1954 (Gojira) Movie Review: One of Cinema’s Greatest Monsters Ever” review text © Dan Schneider; excerpt, image captions, bullet point introduction, awards information, and notes/endnotes © Alt Film Guide.

Godzilla 1954 (Gojira) Movie Review: One of Cinema’s Greatest Monsters Ever” is a condensed/revised version of Dan Schneider’s text currently found in its original form here.


Godzilla 1954 (Gojira) Movie Review” endnotes

Godzilla 1954 and Godzilla, King of the Monsters! cast and crew info via the IMDb and other sources.

Raymond Burr Godzilla, King of the Monsters! image and trailer: Embassy Pictures | TransWorld Releasing Corporation.

Momoko Kôchi, Takashi Shimura, and Akihiko Hirata Godzilla 1954 images: Toho Film.

Godzilla 1954 (Gojira) Movie Review: One of Cinema’s Greatest Monsters Ever” last updated in June 2021.

5 comments

Recommended for You

Leave a Comment

*IMPORTANT*: By using this form you agree with Alt Film Guide's storage and handling of your data (e.g., your IP address). Make sure your comment adds something relevant to the discussion: Feel free to disagree with us, but *thoughtfulness* and *at least a modicum of sanity* are imperative. Abusive, inflammatory, spammy/self-promotional, baseless (spreading mis- or disinformation), and just plain deranged comments will be zapped, and, if we deem appropriate, reported. Lastly, links found in submitted comments will generally be deleted.

5 comments

Connie Chapman -

Twenty seven sequels could not even begin to hold a candle to the sheer power of the original. An American remake wimps out next to the starkness of the original. Even Raymond Burr in all his wooden deadpanning could not wreck the solemnity of the original Godzilla- a testament to the awful power of the atomic bomb.

The events from Pearl Harbor (1941) all the way through to the bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki (1945) were the real world precursor to one of the scariest freaking periods of American history — the arms race. Prior to the surprise attack on Pearl Harbor, Japanese imperialist aggression was literally taking the South Pacific by storm. Guam — the Phillippines — Taiwan — even mainland China, all suffered terribly before the might of the Japanese military.
It was after the raid on Pearl Harbor which wreaked havoc on the US Navy’s Pacific Fleet and destroyed the USS Arizona and USS Oklahoma that one of the Japanese generals solemnly stated “We have awakened a sleeping giant.” His words would eventually be realized on August 1945… not with one, but two atomic weapons, bringing the Japanese to their knees, and World War II to a conclusion.
Less than ten years after the explosions, the Japanese economy still had not made a lot of headway toward bouncing back. There was still much anxiety about the nuclear weapons the United States was constructing- and testing — en masse.
What made the original Godzilla movie so intense was the personal experiences of some of the filmmakers. Several of them had seen firsthand the destruction in Hiroshima and Nagasaki, others had been POW’s in mainland China. It was this wartime experience that they effectively managed to channel into “Godzilla”. Godzilla was an allegory for the horror of war in general and the horror of atomic war in particular, while the direct outcry was against atomic testing.

It was just such an atomic test on the Bikini Atoll that poisoned the crew of the Lucky Dragon #5 and sparked fears anew of nuclear apocalypse. It was this event which was still fresh in the mind of the Japanese public when the first Godzilla movie was born. The images of sailors suddenly crying out as the ocean explodes, running for their lives and all for naught -touched a nerve. (The real Lucky Dragon incident was far more insidious. The crew members saw the bomb flash but did not know what it was, and began scooping up the fallout by the armful intending to take some of it back to their families to show them. Little could they know of what horror awaited them!!!) The images of a huge black terror slowly advancing, only lit by flames, was reminiscent of the night time firebombing raids on Tokyo 10 years before. The rampant carnage portrayed in Godzilla mirrors that of the real life carnage in WWII.

But it is the apolitical message of Godzilla that drives the point home. It is not America or Russia or any other single nation that is solely responsible for unleashing the horrors of the splitting of the atom, it is man. What one man did with E=MC2 Serizawa attempts to undo in the gothic setting of his basement laboratory with the formula for the O2 Destroyer, with mixed results, the eventual destruction of Godzilla along with himself. Godzilla himself is seen as alternately an incarnation of the atomic bomb as well as a victim of it…removed from his own natural habitat, his own natural life span, even seemingly his own mortality, as a creature which should not have been alive but was…at once powerful and…pathetic.

Various angles have been played on the nature of the character Godzilla. Godzilla as a force of nature, Godzilla as the homeland defender, Godzilla as ancient deity, Godzilla the friend of all children, Godzilla the concerned dad. And all are unique in their own manner. But in this day and age where terrorism and amoral brutality runs rampant, where terrorists lust after the power promised them by possession of the Bomb, where even 64 years after the fact we are still haunted by the shadow of the possibility of nuclear conflict, the most relevant is still the Godzilla which is the epitome of mindless, brutal nuclear rage, leaving a path of death and misery in its wake.

And the warning still lives on that in the next armed nuclear conflict a monster may yet arise that even an Oxygen Destroyer may not remedy…

So far, mankind appears to have heeded this warning, as despite being nuclear proliferation, the human race has not yet stepped into the abyss from which there is no return. And if the large black figure with a demonic glare and terrible teeth stationed at the entrance to that abyss still cranks out movie after movie after movie for us to watch because we are still here….

Then he has done his job.

Reply
James V. Mendola -

Dear Mr.Schneider,

I have read a lot of movie reviews and even wrote a few of them myself, and I honestly must say that I found your reviews of Gojira & Godzilla to be among the best written movie reviews I’ve ever had the pleasure to read. I have never really been much of a Godzilla fanatic,(My brother is the
Godzillaphile of the family, while I have always thought the Planet Of The Apes films were the best Sci-Fi/Fantasy films ever made.) But my brother suggested a few times that I should go and check out a few Godzilla movies. So I recently began doing some reading up about them just to see what some of the best known critics have to say about Godzilla and to find out what all the fuss is about. Now after reading your extremely inspired, informative and entertaining reviews, I can’t wait to go out and buy myself a copy of the Double Disc DVD versions of Gojira & Godzilla, King Of The Monsters. I just happen to come across your review by accident recently and even suggested to my brother that he ought to read it too. I’m glad that I took the time to read it all even though I felt like I needed a dictionary and a thesaurus to understand some of it,(lol)this is still one of the best movie or film reviews I ever read. Thank You very much, you may have done what my brother has tried to do a few times, turn me into a Godzillaphile too! If you could just write another article like this about the Planet Of The Apes movies I’d really appreciate it! lol.

Reply
Jeffrey Witt -

Gentelemen: I hope you will add more Ishiro Honda films like “Gojira Raids Again!” (Japanese; 1059) In Japanese -With English subtitles),”The Manster” (JAPAN NSES:1962) IN Japanses;with English Subtitles, and other horror MOVIES MADE IN jAPAN!

Reply
mike -

Dear dan, please excuse my lack of patients and spelling errors. Take in mind that i cannot use the real language that i would normally use. Ever since i could remember i have been a huge godzilla fan. The original movie scarred the hell out me when i was like 6. It blew my mind and for weeks that was all that i could think about. and now that i watch it when im older about 12 years older, and i appreciate it for other reasons.
And i know its hard to admit this. when i was a kid i just kept it botteld up inside. But i have come to a sad conclusion that when i was a child i did not recagnize the fact that in most godzilla movies suck ass! The simple plot of most of the movies just blow me away new and old they suck!
Its difficult for a kaiju fan to admit this but i cant stay silent. I mean look at a movie u mentioned here. (Godzillas Revenge)! HOnestly this movie is the worst peace of human escrimant ive ever laid eyes on. I have considerd to use this a punishment for my kids. PRobobly the worst movie ever made.Its Kind of Funny! But no it isnt funny in a good way its funny that a movie soo seriouse and intellegent can somehow morph into this. A cheap low production peice of garbage.
this isnt the only movie no there are more. Hell my favorite godzilla villan spacegodzilla, is a terrable movie. But it is terrible in a good way. its cheesy and fun but most godzilla movies particuarly the showa series are just alot of mindless plots and stupid looking guys in suits.
Sorry to get off topic But yea godzilla and gojira are very good movies and just a point i didnt feel that raymond burr was outside of the picture like u exclaimed. But then again it wasnt pointed out to me. Um thank u and good review u have alot of presence and carrisma.

Reply
Kaleb Korer -

I hope Godzilla 1985 comings on DVD.

Reply

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. If you continue browsing, that means you've accepted our Terms of Use/use of cookies. You may also click on the Accept button on the right to make this notice disappear. Accept Read More