Alt Film Guide
Classic movies. Gay movies. International cinema. Socially conscious & political cinema.
Home Film ArticlesMovie Reviews Humoresque (1946) Movie Review: Charismatic Joan Crawford Rescues Jean Negulesco’s Ponderous Melodrama

Humoresque (1946) Movie Review: Charismatic Joan Crawford Rescues Jean Negulesco’s Ponderous Melodrama

Humoresque movie 1946 Joan Crawford John GarfieldHumoresque movie (1946) with Joan Crawford and John Garfield.
  • Humoresque (1946) movie review: Joan Crawford exudes star charisma in Jean Negulesco’s stylish but somewhat ponderous melodrama.
  • Humoresque was nominated for one Academy Award: Best Scoring of a Dramatic or Comedy Picture (Franz Waxman).

Humoresque movie review: Jean Negulesco’s melodrama about classical music & class distinctions is saved by a charismatic Joan Crawford

Ramon Novarro biography Beyond Paradise

Directed by Jean Negulesco from a screenplay by Clifford Odets and Zachary Gold – loosely based on Fannie Hurst’s 1919 short story – Warner Bros.’ 1946 version of Humoresque[1] always frustrates me because its first 25 minutes are excruciatingly boring.

And then Joan Crawford makes her appearance in a party scene.

The recent Best Actress Oscar winner (for Mildred Pierce, 1945) plays Helen Wright, a rich society lush in love with a tough-guy violin player, Paul Boray (John Garfield), who happens to be in love with his music.

Fine support is offered by Ruth Nelson and the fabulous chameleon-like J. Carrol Naish as Paul’s parents, Esther and Rudy. On the downside, Oscar Levant plays sarcastic, wisecracking piano player Sid Jeffers to the verge of annoyance.

Something wrong with that woman

The scenes between Paul and his mother are particularly intriguing, as Esther conveys her objections to Helen by lamenting, “There’s something wrong with a woman like that!”

Unfortunately, the highly anticipated confrontation scene between the old lady and the society dame ends much too abruptly, thus offering no resolution.

Near-sighted glamour puss

Then comes The Concert – and that famous Joan Crawford puss goes to work in the close-up. While watching Paul play, she looks as though she is having an orgasm, with her eyes closed and her mouth open.

Crawford never looked better, especially in all those tailored black gowns designed by Adrian (who, at MGM, had dressed her in The Gorgeous Hussy, The Women, Susan and God, etc.).

Now, I always wonder why the near-sighted Helen isn’t wearing glasses in that scene – unless she’s afraid her sultriness would steam them up. Anyway, the glasses seem to be a metaphor for her character’s inability to see that Paul’s music comes first.

Romantic suicide

Lastly, Humoresque offers one of the most romantic suicide scenes in film history: Donning a scintillating evening gown, Joan Crawford walks into the ocean, drowning to the strains of “Liebestod” from Tristan and Isolde as her lover performs a concert on the radio.

As far as I know, apart from Edmund Goulding’s 1925 melodrama Sally, Irene and Mary, Humoresque is the only movie in which Joan Crawford dies.*

He’s got Isaac Stern’s hands

I should add that the only thing that bothers me about the film’s well-made violin scenes is that I keep imagining Isaac Stern standing behind John Garfield with his arms wrapped tightly around the actor while manipulating his instrument.

I’d love to have seen those rehearsals.

* Joan Crawford also dies in Ranald MacDougall’s Queen Bee (1955) and, as mentioned in a comment further below, in David Miller’s The Story of Esther Costello (1957).

Ramon Novarro biography Beyond Paradise

Humoresque (1946) cast & crew

Director: Jean Negulesco.

Screenplay: Clifford Odets & Zachary Gold.
From Fannie Hurst’s 1919 short story “Humoresque: A Laugh on Life with a Tear Behind It.”

Cast: Joan Crawford, John Garfield, Oscar Levant, J. Carrol Naish, Joan Chandler, Ruth Nelson, Tom D’Andrea, Peggy Knudsen, Craig Stevens, Paul Cavanagh, Richard Gaines, John Abbott, Robert Blake, Tommy Cook, Don McGuire, Fritz Leiber.

Cinematography: Ernest Haller.

Film Editing: Rudi Fehr.

Music: Leo F. Forbstein (musical director); Franz Waxman (conductor & additional music).

Art Direction: Hugh Reticker.

Producer: Jerry Wald.

Production Company | Distributor: Warner Bros.

Running Time: 125 min.

Country: United States.

Humoresque Movie (1946): Charismatic Joan Crawford to the Rescue” review text © Danny Fortune; excerpt, image captions, bullet point introduction, and notes/endnotes © Alt Film Guide.

Humoresque (1946) Movie Review: Charismatic Joan Crawford” notes

Golden Boy vibes

[1] Surely it’s no coincidence that Warners’ 1946 movie version of Humoresque, co-written by Clifford Odets, has a number of elements in common with Columbia’s Rouben Mamoulian-directed 1939 movie version of Golden Boy, based on Odets’ 1937 play: Older woman/younger man romance (in Golden Boy, Barbara Stanwyck and William Holden), the world of classical music vs. the world of boxing, the socioeconomic barriers faced by working-class Americans.

Of note, Famous Players-Lasky/Paramount’s more “inspirational” – and hugely popular – 1920 version of Humoresque was directed by future two-time Academy Award winner Frank Borzage (7th Heaven, 1927–28; Bad Girl, 1931–32) from a screenplay by future two-time Academy Award winner Frances Marion (The Big House, 1929–30; The Champ, 1931–32).

The three leads were played by Gaston Glass (as the poor-turned-rich Jewish violinist and eventual World War I vet), Vera Gordon (as his adoring mother, a relatively minor role in the remake), and Alma Rubens (as the local Jewish girl who becomes the violinist’s ever-devoted wife).

Humoresque (1946) Movie Review” endnotes

Humoresque movie credits via the American Film Institute (AFI) website.

John Garfield and Joan Crawford Humoresque movie image: Warner Bros.

Humoresque (1946) Movie Review: Charismatic Joan Crawford Rescues Jean Negulesco’s Ponderous Melodrama” last updated in December 2022.

Recommended for You

Leave a Comment

*IMPORTANT*: By using this form you agree with Alt Film Guide's storage and handling of your data (e.g., your IP address). Make sure your comment adds something relevant to the discussion: Feel free to disagree with us and write your own movie commentaries, but *thoughtfulness* and *at least a modicum of sanity* are imperative. Abusive, inflammatory, spammy/self-promotional, baseless (spreading mis- or disinformation), and just plain deranged comments will be zapped. Lastly, links found in submitted comments will generally be deleted.

1 comment

Ed Miller -

Joan Crawford’s characters also die in “The Story of Esther Costello” and “Night Gallery”.


This website uses cookies to improve your experience. If you continue browsing, that means you've accepted our Terms of Use/use of cookies. You may also click on the Accept button on the right to make this notice disappear. Accept Read More