Directed by George Stevens, The Talk of the Town received seven Academy Award nominations, including Best Picture and two for its story and screenplay. (Back in those days there were three Best Writing categories.) Arthur is outstanding as a schoolteacher – this is perhaps my favorite among her performances – torn between a law professor (an equally outstanding Ronald Colman) and an escaped convict (Cary Grant). As a plus, former Warner Bros. contract player Glenda Farrell is excellent in a supporting role.
The Talk of the Town is not to be missed. Though much less famous than Stevens' prestigious dramas A Place in the Sun, Shane, and Giant, this 1942 socially conscious comedy is just as good as those other titles – if not better.
Personally, I find The Talk of the Town much better than Stevens' most famous comedy, The More the Merrier, in which Arthur, Joel McCrea, and Best Supporting Actor Academy Award winner Charles Coburn must share a flat in overcrowded wartime Washington. Arthur received her sole Best Actress Oscar nomination for her role as the uptight Connie Milligan, who loosens up when she falls for one of her roommates. (No, not Coburn, who plays Cupid in this one.)
I found History Is Made at Night quite weak, but it's worth a look if you haven't watched it before. The romantic comedy elements in the beginning of the film are okay, but this Frank Borzage effort flounders once it turns to heavy drama. Arthur's leading man is Charles Boyer, but Frankenstein's Colin Clive – as her creepy husband – is the one who steals the show. (And I wish he'd drowned Leo Carrillo's Cesare while at it.)
I've never watched The Public Menace. Will rectify that matter shortly, though the presence of George Murphy doesn't make this minor Columbia entry seem very enticing.
Now, I've watched Mr. Deeds Goes to Town several times. Though I'm no fan of Frank Capra's mushiness, which I find, well, mushy (and dishonest), I do enjoy this one because of the chemistry between Arthur and leading man Gary Cooper, in addition to a whole array of solid supporting players, especially Douglas Dumbrille.
5:00 PM THE TALK OF THE TOWN (1942). An escaped political prisoner and a stuffy law professor vie for the hand of a spirited schoolteacher. Dir.: George Stevens. Cast: Cary Grant, Jean Arthur, Ronald Colman, Glenda Farrell. Black and white. 117 min.
7:15 PM HISTORY IS MADE AT NIGHT (1937). A romantic headwaiter fights to save a woman from her possessive ex-husband. Dir.: Frank Borzage. Cast: Charles Boyer, Jean Arthur, Leo Carrillo, Colin Clive. Black and white. 97 min.
9:00 PM THE PUBLIC MENACE (1935). A cocky reporter's marriage to a manicurist jeopardizes his career. Dir.: Erle C. Kenton. Cast: Jean Arthur, George Murphy, Douglass Dumbrille. Black and white. 73 min.
10:30 PM THE MORE THE MERRIER (1943). The World War II housing shortage brings three people together for an unlikely romance. Dir.: George Stevens. Cast: Jean Arthur, Joel McCrea, Charles Coburn. Black and white. 104 min.
12:30 AM MR. DEEDS GOES TO TOWN (1936). When he inherits a fortune, a small-town poet has to deal with the corruption of city life. Dir.: Frank Capra. Cast: Gary Cooper, Jean Arthur, George Bancroft. Black and white. 116 min.