Alt Film Guide
Classic movies. Gay movies. International cinema. Socially conscious & political cinema.
Home Movie Awards Julia Roberts’ Golden Globes + Gabourey Sidibe Possibly Cheated Out of Award

Julia Roberts’ Golden Globes + Gabourey Sidibe Possibly Cheated Out of Award

6 minutes read

Duplicity Julia Roberts: Golden Globe winner in all 3 categories available for actresses
Duplicity with Julia Roberts. Three-time Golden Globe winner Julia Roberts not only is a (somewhat, considering the Hollywood Foreign Press Association) surprising nominee in the Best Actress – Comedy or Musical category, but she’ll also be a presenter at the 2010 ceremony to be held in Beverly Hills. Roberts’ three Golden Globes were for performances shortlisted in each of the big-screen categories available for actresses: Best Supporting Actress (Steel Magnolias, 1989), Best Actress – Comedy or Musical (Pretty Woman, 1990), and Best Actress – Drama (Erin Brockovich, 2000).

Golden Globe nominations Up in the Air

Ramon Novarro Beyond Paradise

Topping the crowded and highly eclectic Golden Globe field with six nominations, Jason Reitman’s Up in the Air was shortlisted as a drama, not a comedy (or musical). James Cameron’s blockbuster-in-the-making Avatar also made the cut in that category, which basically meant that Peter Jackson’s The Lovely Bones and Clint Eastwood’s Invictus went out the window.

And so did our predictions for the Golden Globes’ Best Picture – Drama category. Indeed, the only two movies we got right were Kathryn Bigelow’s Iraq War drama The Hurt Locker and Lee Daniels’ dysfunctional family drama Precious.

It’s an outrage. Really, how could the Hollywood Foreign Press Association voters pick something dark and violent like Quentin Tarantino’s Inglourious Basterds instead of something sunny and genteel like (our prediction) Michael Hoffman’s The Last Station, which has Helen Mirren, Christopher Plummer, and Leo Tolstoy?

‘Best Picture – Comedy or Drama’ category

Besides, the Golden Globes often have dramas in the more sparsely populated comedy or musical category, but this year they just had to go the other way.

Not that Up in the Air is an out-and-out comedy – and there’s certainly nothing funny about the current unemployment figures in the U.S. – but we felt that the HFPA would classify Reitman’s film as such so as to leave more room in their Best Picture – Drama category for the likes of The Last Station, The Lovely Bones, and the uplifting “We Are the World, We Are the People” Invictus.

Now, at this stage, things don’t look at all lovely for The Lovely Bones, which has received several negative (or quasi-negative) reviews, while being basically ignored by U.S.-based voting groups. At the Golden Globes, this supernatural drama about a murdered girl in heaven and her murderer on Earth received only one nod: Best Supporting Actor for Stanley Tucci’s psycho child-hater.

Would-be Best Picture – Drama nominees

And here are other possibilities in the Best Picture – Drama category that were left off of the HFPA roster, thus somewhat diminishing their awards season publicity and, potentially, Oscar chances:

  • Lone Scherfig’s An Education.
  • Jim Sheridan’s Brothers.
  • Jane Campion’s Bright Star.
  • Kirk Jones’ Everybody’s Fine.
  • John Hillcoat’s The Road.

The last three, in fact, were left completely Golden Globe nominationless. An Education, for its part, managed to get one nod for star Carey Mulligan, while Brothers earned nods for Tobey Maguire and for the U2 song “Winter.” And that means … Bono at the party?

Update: Check out the full list of the 2009 Golden Globes’ winners & nominees.

Golden Globe presenters: Julia Roberts & Jennifer Aniston

Update: Golden Globe winners Julia Roberts, Jennifer Aniston, and Mickey Rourke have been set as presenters at the 2010 Golden Globes ceremony, to be held on Sunday, Jan. 17.

Hosted by Ricky Gervais, in the U.S. the show will be broadcast live coast to coast on NBC (5–8 p.m. PT/8–11 p.m. ET) from the Beverly Hilton Hotel in Beverly Hills.

Aniston, Roberts, and Rourke join the previously announced Robert De Niro and Leonardo DiCaprio, who will present the Cecil B. DeMille Award to their, respectively, Taxi Driver and The Aviator director, Martin Scorsese.

Current Golden Globe nominee & three-time winner Julia Roberts

This year, Julia Roberts is a surprise nominee in the Best Actress – Comedy or Musical category for the box office disappointment Duplicity. Directed by Tony Gilroy and featuring Roberts’ Closer co-star Clive Owen, Duplicity follows a pair of corporate spies attempting to con their own bosses.

To date, Roberts has seven Golden Globe nominations; she won three times:

  • Best Supporting Actress for Steel Magnolias (1989).
  • Best Actress – Comedy or Musical for Pretty Woman (1990).
  • Best Actress – Drama for Erin Brockovich (2000), which also earned her a Best Actress Oscar.

Back in 2003, Jennifer Aniston won a Golden Globe for Best Performance by an Actress in a Television Series – Comedy or Musical for her work in the hit series Friends.

Mickey Rourke isn’t up for any Golden Globes this year, but he did win in the Best Actor – Drama category last year for Darren Aronofsky’s The Wrestler. The Best Actor Oscar, however, went to Sean Penn for Gus Van Sant’s Milk.

Gabourey Sidibe Precious. African-American Critics' actual Best Actress winner?
Gabourey Sidibe in Precious: The African-American Film Critics Association’s actual Best Actress winner? Nicole Beharie was the announced Best Actress for her performance in Tim Disney’s little-seen and, this awards season, wholly ignored American Violet. But there have been questions about the veracity of the announcement, as Gabourey Sidibe seems to have been the one with the most votes for her widely acclaimed work in Lee Daniels’ family drama that will likely earn her a Best Actress Oscar nomination.

Gabourey Sidibe the actual African-American Film Critics’ Best Actress winner?

In other awards season news, according to The Hollywood Reporter‘s Roger Friedman, Precious’ Gabourey Sidibe may have been cheated out of a Best Actress award.

This past Dec. 14, the African-American Film Critics Association gave Precious awards for Best Picture, Best Director (Lee Daniels), Best Supporting Actress (Mo’Nique) and Best Screenplay (Geoffrey Fletcher).

Their Best Actress, however, was Nicole Beharie for American Violet, a little-seen socially conscious drama directed by Tim Disney (great-nephew of Walt Disney) and written by Bill Haney, who also produced it. Some within the AAFCA now assert that Sidibe was the actual winner.

“According to the final ballot, which this reporter has seen,” writes Friedman, “Sidibe received eight first-place votes from the 16 critics who participated. Beharie got four first-place finishes, and the rest went to Anika Noni Rose (two votes) and one each for Helen Mirren and Zooey Deschanel. Among second-place finishers, Sidibe got five votes; Beharie got one.”

Pleasing ‘American Violet’ producers

AAFCA co-founder Gil Robertson IV has been accused of manipulating the final tally “to please the producers of American Violet.” Robertson has defended himself by claiming that Friedman had seen an incomplete tally, as the AAFCA has a total of 22 members. Yet not every member sees things Robertson’s way.

“As you know your recent actions have been called into question because of a series of choices you made without the approval of the founding members of the group, including myself,” AAFCA President Wilson Morales wrote in an email to Robertson.

“Our collective view is that an organization that gives out awards should be ethical and not subjected to bias based on donations from outside sources,” Morales added.

See also: “Critics’ Choices: French Family Drama Tops + Hollywood Nightmare Is Best Film of the Decade.”


Golden Globes website.

Julia Roberts Duplicity image: Relativity Media / Universal Pictures.

Gabourey Sidibe Precious image: Anne Marie Fox / Lionsgate Pictures.

“Julia Roberts’ Golden Globes + Gabourey Sidibe Cheated Out of Best Actress Award?” last updated in April 2018.

Recommended for You

Leave a Comment

*IMPORTANT*: By using this form you agree with Alt Film Guide's storage and handling of your data (e.g., your IP address). Make sure your comment adds something relevant to the discussion: Feel free to disagree with us and write your own movie commentaries, but *thoughtfulness* and *at least a modicum of sanity* are imperative. Abusive, inflammatory, spammy/self-promotional, baseless (spreading mis- or disinformation), and just plain deranged comments will be zapped. Lastly, links found in submitted comments will generally be deleted.

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. If you continue browsing, that means you've accepted our Terms of Use/use of cookies. You may also click on the Accept button on the right to make this notice disappear. Accept Privacy Policy