Alt Film Guide
Classic movies. Gay movies. International cinema. Socially conscious & political cinema.
Home Movie CraftsActors + Actresses Legion d’Honneur: Salma Hayek Controversy + Marthe Keller on ‘Unspoiled Monster’ Billy Wilder

Legion d’Honneur: Salma Hayek Controversy + Marthe Keller on ‘Unspoiled Monster’ Billy Wilder

Salma Hayek Mexican actress Legion of Honor controversy
Salma Hayek: Legion d’Honneur controversy.

Salma Hayek: Legion d’Honneur controversy

Ramon Novarro biography Beyond Paradise

There hasn’t been much buzz about Marthe Keller’s induction into France’s Legion of Honor. Or the induction of actresses Dominique Blanc and Anny Duperey. Hardly a surprise, since the only film people that matter in the U.S. (or English-language) media are those with Hollywood careers. And that takes us to another 2012 Chevalier inductee, Mexican actress Salma Hayek, 45, whose honor has received quite a bit more U.S. media play.

But why?

Salma Hayek movies

For starters, Salma Hayek is a Hollywood star. Below are three of her notable – whether critically or commercially – American films.

  • Frida (2002), which earned her a Best Actress Academy Award nomination. (She lost to Nicole Kidman as Virginia Woolf in Stephen Daldry’s The Hours.)
    Director: Julie Taymor.
    Cast: Salma Hayek (as Frida Kahlo). Alfred Molina (as Diego Rivera). Edward Norton (as Nelson Rockefeller). Diego Luna. Antonio Banderas (as David Alfaro Siqueiros). Mia Maestro. Valeria Golino. Geoffrey Rush (as Leon Trotsky). Roger Rees.
  • Once Upon a Time in Mexico (2003).
    Director: Robert Rodriguez.
    Cast: Antonio Banderas. Salma Hayek. Eva Mendes. Johnny Depp. Enrique Iglesias. Marco Leonardi. Mickey Rourke. Danny Trejo. Cheech Marin. Pedro Armendáriz Jr. Rubén Blades. Willem Dafoe. Julio Oscar Mechoso. Miguel Couturier.
  • Grown Ups (2010).
    Director: Dennis Dugan.
    Cast: Adam Sandler. Kevin James. David Spade. Maria Bello. Salma Hayek. Rob Schneider. Chris Rock. Maya Rudolph. Joyce Van Patten. Steve Buscemi.

Hayek’s other film credits include more Hollywood or semi-Hollywood productions such as Desperado, From Dusk Til Dawn, After the Sunset, Once Upon a Time in Mexico, and the animated hit Puss in Boots. Besides, she is now reportedly working on a biopic of Mexican cinema superstar María Félix (Enamorada, Doña Diabla).

Now, are Puss in Boots and one Best Actress Oscar nod enough to warrant Legion of Honor “membership”?

Chevalier Salma

Salma Hayek’s inclusion on this year’s Legion of Honor roster has been criticized by those asserting that French president Nicolas Sarkozy is using the ceremony for political gain in an election year. Hayek’s father-in-law, François Pinault, the founder of PPR (the French owner of Gucci and Puma, among other businesses), will also be inducted as a Grand Officer.

Hence, Hayek will be this year’s Legion of Honor Beauty; Pinault, the Legion of Honor Bosom Buddy Billionaire. After all, the business magnate is a close friend of Sarkozy – who, three years ago, legion-honored the judge who pronounced his divorce from his then wife, (now known as) Cécilia Attias.

But in all fairness, Nicolas Sarkozy is hardly the only French president to have bestowed the Legion of Honor honor for the sake of his own popularity and/or private/political interests. For instance, in a calculated populist move, in 1998 Jacques Chirac decided to honor the French soccer team after their winning the World Cup.

UNICEF ambassador, refuseniks

Those who believe Hayek deserves the honor emphasize her charity work, her support for women victims of domestic violence, and the fact that she has been a UNICEF ambassador since 2008.

And finally … Among those whom honoree Salma Hayek will not be joining in the Légion d’Honneur Hall of Fame are Marie Curie, Pierre Curie, Claude Monet, George Sand, Guy de Maupassant, Simone de Beauvoir, Jean-Paul Sartre, and Albert Camus. These were some of the would-be inductees who refused to accept the French government’s Honor.

Marthe Keller actress Legion of HonorMarthe Keller: Actress in more than 40 movies – among them And Now My Love and Marathon Man – to become Legion of Honor chevalier.

Actress Marthe Keller to become Légion d’Honneur chevalier

Veteran actress Marthe Keller, among whose film credits are Claude Lelouch’s And Now My Love and John Schlesinger’s Marathon Man, will be inducted as a chevalier (“knight”) in the French Legion of Honor, a civilian distinction that has been around since the days of Napoleon Bonaparte in the early 1800s.

Born in Basel, Switzerland, Keller – whose dream of becoming a professional dancer was shattered by a skiing accident – will turn 67 in about three weeks (Jan. 28, ’12). In the last 45 years, she has appeared in more than 40 films, both in leading and supporting roles.

Marthe Keller movies: Hollywood flops

Apart from the aforementioned – ludicrous but financially successful – Marathon Man (1976), in which the Best Supporting Actress Golden Globe nominee was featured opposite pacifist New Yorker Dustin Hoffman and sadistic Nazi Laurence Olivier, Keller had little luck in her several Hollywood try-outs in the late ’70s.

  • She was a Palestinian Black September terrorist in John Frankenheimer’s failed thriller Black Sunday (1977), toplining Robert Shaw and Bruce Dern – the latter as a demented former Vietnam War captive and Goodyear Blimp pilot.
  • She romanced Al Pacino – who became her real-life companion – in Sydney Pollack’s expensive autoracing flop Bobby Deerfield (1977).
  • She was a mysterious, Greta Garbo-ish former actress pursued by William Holden in Billy Wilder’s critical and box office bomb Fedora (1978), based on one of the stories found in Tom Tryon’s book Crowned Heads.
  • She was wasted alongside George C. Scott and Marlon Brando in a convoluted tale about big business corruption and gas prices in John G. Avildsen’s thriller The Formula (1980).

‘Unspoiled Monster’ Billy Wilder

April 2016 update: Referring to Truman Capote’s “Unspoiled Monsters,” Keller would tell Télérama magazine that she met many such creatures during her Hollywood sojourn.

“The worst of which, by far, was Billy Wilder,” she recalled. “Of course, who am I to dare criticize such a genius? Whatever. This genius made me suffer like no one else in the world. He came to see me one evening, a screenplay under his arm. ‘It’s for you! You’re the only one who can play Fedora…’ And that’s when my private hell began. Each syllable, each gesture were measured in millimeters.”

She added that upon its release Fedora brought her the “most scathing reviews of her life. Today, the film is a classic. They even find me appropriate…”

Besides Marthe Keller, Fedora features William Holden, Hildegarde Knef, José Ferrer, Frances Sternhagen, Mario Adorf, Stephen Collins, and Ferdy Mayne, plus cameos by Michael York, Henry Fonda, and Arlene Francis.

Marthe Keller Fedora directed by unspoiled monster Billy Wilder with Henry FondaMarthe Keller in ‘Fedora,’ directed by ‘unspoiled monster’ Billy Wilder and featuring Henry Fonda.

Better cinematic luck elsewhere

At least when it comes to movie awards, Marthe Keller had better luck far away from the Hollywood studios.

In addition to the romantic tale And Now My Love / Toute une vie (1974), a Best Original Screenplay Oscar nominee that has inspired movies as disparate as Krzysztof Kieslowski’s Red and Nora Ephron’s Sleepless in Seattle, Keller herself was shortlisted for awards for her performances in:

Genie Award nomination in the Best Performance by a Foreign Actress category for playing revenge-bent Savage’s CIA contact.

  • Dark Eyes / Oci ciornie (1987).
    Director: Nikita Mikhalkov.
    Cast: Marcello Mastroianni. Marthe Keller. Elena Safonova.

Best Supporting Actress David di Donatello nomination for playing Mastroianni’s mistress. (Mastroianni, for his part, was shortlisted for the Best Actor Academy Award.)

  • Fragile (2005).
    Director: Laurent Nègre.
    Cast: Marthe Keller. Felipe Castro. Stefanie Gunther.

Best Supporting Actress Swiss Film Prize winner for playing a woman in the throes of Alzheimer’s.

Marthe Keller discusses ‘Hereafter.’

Recent films, early French TV hit

More recently, Marthe Keller was seen in:

  • Clint Eastwood’s Hereafter (2010).
  • Wolfgang Murnberger’s My Best Enemy / Mein bester Feind (2011).
  • Bouli Lanners’ The Giants / Les géants (2011).

Also worth mentioning is Luís Galvão Teles’ Portuguese dramatic comedy Elles (1997), starring Keller alongside Carmen Maura, Miou-Miou, and Marisa Berenson as – French-speaking – Lisbon denizens at odds with husbands, children, and life in general.

And, on French television, the 1972 hit La ­Demoiselle d’Avignon…, which made her a star in France. In the miniseries she plays a princess from the country of Kurland, having a long-distance relationship of sorts with a local Avignon archeologist (Louis Velle): he goes to Kurland looking for her, she comes to Avignon looking for him.

Tony nominee and opera director

Marthe Keller’s performance in a 2001 Broadway staging of Abby Mann’s Judgment at Nuremberg – as Mme. Bertholt (Marlene Dietrich in Stanley Kramer’s 1961 film) – earned her a Best Featured Actress Tony Award nomination. (She lost to Viola Davis for King Hedley II.)

In recent decades, Keller has also become a “speaker” in classical music presentations and an opera director. As a speaker, she played Joan of Arc in the oratorio Jeanne d’Arc au Bûcher of Arthur Honegger, recited the spoken role in Igor Stravinsky’s Perséphone, and toplined Michael Jarrell’s Cassandre, adapted from Christa Wolf’s novel as a star vehicle for her.

Her credits as an opera director include Dialogues des Carmélites for Opéra National du Rhin in Strasbourg, Lucia di Lammermoor for the Washington National Opera and the Los Angeles Opera, and Don Giovanni for New York City’s Metropolitan Opera.

Philippe and Alexandre de Broca

In the early 1970s, Marthe Keller was in a relationship with filmmaker Philippe de Broca, whose credits include The Man from Rio (1964), with Jean-Paul Belmondo and Françoise Dorléac, and Le Magnifique (1973), with Belmondo and Jacqueline Bisset.

Their son, Alexandre de Broca, is a painter and has done set/production design for a handful of film/TV productions, i.e., Guillaume Casset’s animated short Tous les I de Paris s’illuminent (1999), Nicolas Bary’s Les enfants de Timpelbach (2008).

Keller has never been married “to avoid the violence of divorce.”

Marthe Keller image via the UniFrance website.

Marthe Keller’s comment re: divorce via Télérama.

‘Farewell My Queen’ to open Berlin Film Festival

The world premiere of Les Adieux à la reine / Farewell, My Queen will open the 2012 Berlin Film Festival next February 9. Directed by Benoît Jacquot (Tosca, Villa Amalia, Deep in the Woods), Farewell, My Queen stars Inglourious Basterds’ Diane Kruger (as Marie Antoinette), Midnight in Paris’ Léa Seydoux, and Army of Crime‘s Virginie Ledoyen.

Adapted by Jacquot and Gilles Taurand from Chantal Thomas’ novel, Farewell, My Queen is set during the first days of the French Revolution, as seen from the perspective of the servants at Versailles. The synopsis below is from the Berlin Film Festival website:

Versailles in July 1789. Unrest is growing in the court of King Louis the XVI (Xavier Beauvois). The people are rebelling – a revolution is imminent. Behind the facades of the royal palaces, everyone is thinking of fleeing, including Queen Marie Antoinette (Diane Kruger) and her entourage. Among her ladies-in-waiting is Sidonie Laborde (Léa Seydoux) who as the Queen’s reader has become quite intimate with her. With great amazement, Sidonie experiences the first hours of the French Revolution.

Prior to Kruger, previous portrayers of Marie Antoinette on screen include Norma Shearer, Oscar nominated in 1938 for W. S. Van Dyke’s Marie Antoinette; Michèle Morgan in Jean Delannoy’s Marie-Antoinette reine de France / Shadow of the Guillotine, (1956); Kirsten Dunst in Sofia Coppola’s Marie Antoinette (2006); Joely Richardson in Charles Shyer’s The Affair of the Necklace (2001); Nina Foch in George Sidney’s Scaramouche (1952); Anita Louise in William Dieterle’s Madame Du Barry (1934); and Julia Swayne Gordon in Ralph Ince’s My Lady’s Slipper (1916).

In addition to serving as the Berlinale’s opening night gala presentation, Farewell, My Queen will also be in the running for the 2012 Golden Bear. As announced previously, Meryl Streep will receive this year’s Honorary Golden Bear.

Diane Kruger/Farewell My Queen photo: Lumiere

Tobey Maguire The Great Gatsby Leonardo DiCaprio Carey Mulligan hip and heavy dramaTobey Maguire and Carey Mulligan at the forefront of ‘The Great Gatsby,’ with Leonardo DiCaprio and Joel Edgerton in the background: Serious cast in hip and heavy drama.

Tobey Maguire and Carey Mulligan in early 21st century ‘The Great Gatsby’

In Baz Luhrmann’s upcoming film adaptation – co-written with Craig Pearce – of F. Scott Fitzgerald’s classic 1920s novel The Great Gatsby Leonardo DiCaprio (he of Titanic, The Aviator, and Inception fame) plays the titular filthy rich party host Jay Gatsby, who has an adulterous affair with the married Daisy Buchanan (Carey Mulligan), whose brutish husband, Tom (Joel Edgerton), also happens to be having a fling with another woman, the low-class Myrtle (Isla Fisher).

As Nick Carraway, the narrator who also happens to be more than a tad infatuated with the ruggedly mysterious Gatsby, former Spider-Man Tobey Maguire tries to keep all the different affairs straight, so to speak.

Leonardo DiCaprio, Tobey Maguire, Carey Mulligan (An Education, Shame), and Joel Edgerton (Animal Kingdom, Warrior) can all be seen in the recently released The Great Gatsby image above. Missing in action is Isla Fisher (Confessions of a Shopaholic, Wedding Crashers). Understandably so, as the setting is much too glamorous for her character.

20th century ‘The Great Gatsby’ movies

There have been three previous big-screen Hollywood version of F. Scott Fitzgerald’s novel. The first one, which came out during the silent era, was directed by Herbert Brenon in 1926. More than two decades later, Brenon’s now lost silent was followed by Elliott Nugent’s much altered 1949 version and, a quarter of a century later, by Jack Clayton’s more straightforward take on the novel in 1974.

The previous Jay Gatsby actors:

The previous Daisy Buchanan actresses:

Baz Luhrmann’s The Great Gatsby is set to open on Dec. 25. The period drama will be Leonardo DiCaprio’s second major 3D release this year, as James Cameron’s 3D-converted Titanic, costarring Kate Winslet and Gloria Stuart, opens in the spring.

Check out: Robert Redford ‘The Great Gatsby’.

Leonardo DiCaprio, Carey Mulligan, Joel Edgerton, and Tobey Maguire The Great Gatsby image: Warner Bros.

Recommended for You

Leave a Comment

*IMPORTANT*: By using this form you agree with Alt Film Guide's storage and handling of your data (e.g., your IP address). Make sure your comment adds something relevant to the discussion: Feel free to disagree with us and write your own movie commentaries, but *thoughtfulness* and *at least a modicum of sanity* are imperative. Abusive, inflammatory, spammy/self-promotional, baseless (spreading mis- or disinformation), and just plain deranged comments will be zapped. Lastly, links found in submitted comments will generally be deleted.


Eva Callicutt -

Jacob Ortiz is my Neices son and we are so proud of him and I just want to say ” Thank You ” for the chance you gave Jacob. Sincerely, Eva Callicutt, Nampa , Idaho

Ricardo Andres -

Working opposite. Alice Braga has been a highlight of my career. Jacob Ortiz as my grandson was fun. I’ll use him in my movie, the Deadliest Gun.

Stephanie Niko -

I’m so excited to see this! Do we have US dates yet?


This website uses cookies to improve your experience. If you continue browsing, that means you've accepted our Terms of Use/use of cookies. You may also click on the Accept button on the right to make this notice disappear. Accept Read More