Lon McCallister and William Eythe: Forbidden Gay Romance?

Lon McCallister gay actor William Eythe loverLon McCallister: Height, gay sexual orientation issues

[See previous post: "Lon McCallister Bio."] Some have blamed Lon McCallister's slight frame for his inability to switch from juvenile to leading-man roles, but that's absurd. Had that been so, Alan Ladd and Charles Boyer, among others, would never have become top stars in the '30s and '40s.

Others have blamed his professional downfall on the fact that Lon McCallister was gay. Though certainly a possibility (see below), barring the publication of unquestionable proof or strong circumstantial evidence – I'm unaware of the existence of any such evidence – that would be also open to debate. After all, Montgomery Clift, for one, became a top star right at the time McCallister's Hollywood career was coming to a close, while Van Johnson would remain an important leading man at MGM and elsewhere for another decade.

Lon McCallister and William Eythe: Forbidden gay romance in the late '40s?

Lon McCallister had a longtime relationship with fellow Fox contract player William Eythe, probably best remembered for playing Jennifer Jones' (sort-of) love interest in The Song of Bernadette, Linda Darnell's suitor in Otto Preminger's blockbuster Centennial Summer, and the good-looking lieutenant sandwiched between Anne Baxter and Tallulah Bankhead in Preminger's A Royal Scandal.

Eythe, who had a reputation for being “difficult,” had a troubled professional relationship with Fox honcho Darryl F. Zanuck. In 1947, with Tyrone Power, Victor Mature, and others returning from service, plus Gregory Peck and Dana Andrews on the studio payroll, Fox severed ties with their recalcitrant actor.

That same year, Eythe married minor Fox contract player and humorist Irvin S. Cobb's granddaughter Buff Cobb. The couple were divorced in early 1949, after Cobb, shortly to become the wife of television personality Mike Wallace, accused Eythe of hitting her.

His movie career over in the early '50s, Eythe went briefly on stage. But by then an already serious alcohol problem became uncontrollable; Eythe was to die of acute hepatitis at age 38 in 1957. The Associated Press' obit read: “With him when he died was his close friend, former actor Lon McCallister, with whom he had been producing travel films.”

So, of course, depending on when their relationship began, it's certainly possible that McCallister was a victim of the animosity between Eythe and Zanuck. But if so, why was Eythe let go in 1947, while McCallister was to remain at the studio another three years? (Motion Picture, 1947: “If you yearn silently for Lon McCallister, then here's your chance, girls. Seems Lon's looking for a lassie to call his own. 'But there's a catch to it,' he tells us. 'She must be willing to stay home every night – except Saturday. I work all week and that's the only night I can make whoopee.'”)

Now, although a Darryl Zanuck-engendered anti-gay backlash is a possible explanation for the demise of Lon McCallister's once-promising Hollywood career, it's worth bearing in mind that an actor, especially one with a fast-receding hairline, can't go on playing juveniles forever. McCallister's persona – much like that of Mickey Rooney (and, say, Johnny Downs and Jackie Cooper before them) – failed to mature along with his looks; that, quite possibly more than anything else, was what ultimately killed his chances of real film stardom.

I should add that according to a couple of McCallister's friends I met while working on the Ramon Novarro biography Beyond Paradise, the Home in Indiana star had always been quite circumspect about his sexual orientation outside his circle of close friends.

Lon McCallister obit: William Eythe omitted

At the age of 82 and after being in poor health for some time, Lon McCallister died of heart failure in the Lake Tahoe area, Calif., on June 11, 2005. Curiously, though not surprisingly, the Los Angeles Times' Lon McCallister obit left unmentioned both William Eythe and the fact that McCallister was gay.

While working on my Novarro book, I tried contacting McCallister. Unfortunately, he never responded. His friends did get in touch with him on my behalf, but McCallister claimed he knew nothing that could have helped my project. We were never to connect directly.

Note: This two-part Lon McCallister article is an expanded version of a brief obit posted in June 2005.

AP obit quote via Kay Francis biographer Scott O'Brien.

  Lon McCallister and William Eythe: Forbidden Gay Romance? © 2004–2018 Alt Film Guide and/or author(s).
Text NOT to be reproduced without prior written consent.

Leave a comment about “Lon McCallister and William Eythe: Forbidden Gay Romance?”

NOTE: Comments are moderated before publication. *Thoughtfulness* and *at least a modicum of sanity* are imperative. Abusive/bigoted, trollish/inflammatory, baseless (spreading misinformation), spammy, and/or just plain deranged comments will be zapped. Links found in comments will generally be deleted.



  1. Derek Bampton,RSM says:

    The various comments reveal more about the writers than they
    perhaps realize…..during the many years of living in Europe,
    it struck me how interested in penises and pussies those
    people were who neither met nor knew the personalities
    of whom they spoke….and they denied that their beloved stars
    couldn't have been naughty,just sour grapes from those who
    made up (fabricated) lies….as if…..I was in Vienna when Yul
    Brynner was filming THE JOURNEY,and he had an affair with
    Frances Martin,the daughter of a famed Burgtheatre actress,
    which resulted in a child being born…..to his credit,the mother
    received payments for some time…..I have seen some surprising
    behaviour from stars who thought that they wouldn't be
    recognized,because they were in central Europe,but the naysayers
    in America,who normally are quite gullible,wouldn't believe a
    word……….and you wonder that they swallow the words from
    USA's resident clown? Please google Emmet Till….RIP son.

  2. nmvince says:

    I enjoyed watching both actors, Lon McCallister and William Eythe and could care less about their being gay. How sad for both of them not to be able to express their love openly. Did Lon ever find another love?

  3. Brian Carl says:

    After watching the film The Red house I had to Google Lon McCallister and of course my instincts were right he had a beauty and a sensitivity that I sensed right away said to me the tortured lives these men seem to have to have lead order to maneuver around Hollywood. I'm glad to have them recorded on film for me to appreciate their beauty and how hard their lives must have been and it also makes me appreciate how lucky I have it today but I don't have to live that way

  4. Andre says:

    Thanks for posting the comment, Scott.
    It's curious that as per the AP Lon McCallister was with William Eythe when he died — but according to Carol Channing's recollections, SHE was there an McCallister was "nowhere around."

  5. Nicely done, Andre. I found it interesting that Eythe was influential in jump-starting the career of Carol Channing with his 1948 production of "Lend An Ear." It was the break which put her in "Gentlemen Prefer Blondes." The two became lifelong friends–he was frequently her escort. At one point Carol, Eythe and Lon paled-around Istanbul together. When Eythe was dying, Lon mad a concerted effort to find Carol so she could come to the hospital. Years earlier, Eythe had predicted that Channing would be at his side when he died. She got there in time. In her 2002 memoir "Just Lucky I Guess," Channing wrote: "When the moment came, I was the only one with him. Bud (Lon McAllister) was nowhere around when Bill died, and I know he wanted to be. … I didn't know that I was being used as a beard for him and Bud, but it doesn't matter, because Bill and I instinctively protected each other."

  6. Chandler75 says:

    My understanding was that there were photos published of Eythe and McAllister in London, and Zanuck had a fit. Eythe basically got married as a cover-up and possibly at the insistence of the studio. Eythe was pushed into lesser films and finally Zanuck got rid of him.

    Both Zanuck and Louis B advised their matinee idols NOT to get married , but if there were rumors, they insisted upon it. Meyer pressured Van Johnson to get married, and Johnson said the only woman he would consider marrying was Evie Wynn – they were neighbors. Zanuck used Keenan's contract renewal to get Evie to divorce him and marry Van. She managed Johnson's career for a time and was instrumental in him losing the lead in the TV series "The Untouchables" by holding Desi Arnaz up for more money at the last minute. Arnaz called Robert Stack from a pay phone in a restaurant and had him start filming the next day.

    I would say McAllister was less valuable to his studio. There are instances where a studio didn't care what you did.