HomeMovie ReviewsMildred Pierce 1945 Movie Review: ‘Terrific’ Crawford in … Film Noir or Melodrama?

Mildred Pierce 1945 Movie Review: ‘Terrific’ Crawford in … Film Noir or Melodrama?

Mildred Pierce1945 movie: Her two-decade Hollywood career in the doldrums, Joan Crawford made a triumphant comeback in Warners’ expertly made film noir – or is it a melodrama? – that earned the former MGM star a Best Actress Oscar. (Pictured: Joan Crawford and Ann Blyth in Mildred Pierce 1945.)
  • Mildred Pierce (1945) movie review: Best Actress Academy Award winner Joan Crawford delivers a “terrific” performance as an entrepreneurial waitress and self-sacrificing mother in director Michael Curtiz and (credited) screenwriter Ranald MacDougall’s adaptation of James M. Cain’s novel.
  • Now, is Mildred Pierce 1945 truly a film noir or is it “just” an atmospheric melodrama?

Mildred Pierce 1945 movie review: Joan Crawford delivers a remarkable performance in ‘very entertaining’ melodrama

Time has a way of making some films seem grander than they really are. A good example is Mildred Pierce 1945, the black-and-white melodrama directed by Casablanca’s Michael Curtiz and that won star Joan Crawford a Best Actress Oscar.

Mildred Pierce is in no way, shape, or form great art, even though it’s certainly not a bad film. In fact, as a soap opera it’s quite entertaining – no, make that very entertaining; and entertainment is a quality that can stand on its own. (The problem in recent decades is that cinema has become nothing but entertainment.) In the case of Mildred Pierce, the entertainment is formulaic and rather predictable – but in an enjoyable, campy sort of way.

Now, what makes Mildred Pierce a melodrama is something known as the Dumbest Possible Action – DPA for short. That’s when a character does something stupid merely to push the story onward.

One such DPA takes place near the beginning, when restaurant owner Mildred Pierce (Joan Crawford) brings a witness to her home where her second husband, Monte Beragon (Zachary Scott), has been murdered. Mildred is clearly trying to incriminate herself. The problem is that we know early on she is not the murderess and so do the cops. The very stupidity of her action makes it plain that she is covering for another party.

Howzitdun mystery

In the film’s lengthy flashback, we learn that housewife-turned-waitress Mildred is ashamed of her impoverished childhood, which allows her daughter Veda (Ann Blyth) to exploit this at every opportunity. That includes having the black family maid, Lottie (Gone with the Wind actress Butterfly McQueen), wear Mildred’s waitress uniform. It’s a sinister little touch, but one that raises a red flag for the film’s denouement.

In fact, it’s clear early on that Veda has romantic eyes for Beragon and that Mildred is incapable of murder. Logically, the only person who could have killed Beragon is Veda, who is shown as a budding sociopath throughout the film. In other words, there is no real drama in Mildred Pierce.

So, if the solution to the “murder mystery” is obvious from the first few minutes, why do I recommend Mildred Pierce 1945?

Because the film is not really a whodunit but a howzitdun. Also, despite the archetypal nature of many of the characters, Mildred Pierce is remarkably well acted.

‘Terrific’ Joan Crawford

Joan Crawford is terrific as the over-the-top masochistic Mildred; one revels in her dilemmas, even to the point of enjoying what Veda will do to her next.

Zachary Scott’s Beragon set one the templates for playboy types in future films, right on down to David Strathairn’s Pierce Patchett in L.A. Confidential. And Bruce Bennett is solid as Mildred’s first husband.

Yet Mildred Pierce truly belongs to the other secondary characters.

Eve Arden’s Ida, Mildred’s wisecracking friend, is funny and profane – her best line is when she tells Beragon he avoids work because he was “frightened by a callus at an early age.”

Jo Ann Marlowe’s Kay, Mildred’s good daughter, is as sweet a creation as Ann Blyth’s Veda is a spoiled bitch. Besides, Marlowe is delightful impersonating Carmen Miranda singing “South American Way.”

Lastly, Jack Carson is superb as a slick-talking, lead-with-his-dick hustler.

Mildred Pierce 1945 with Joan Crawford and Zachary Scott. As the story goes, among the actresses considered for the title role in the film version of James M. Cain’s novel were Barbara Stanwyck, Bette Davis, and Ann Sheridan. Ultimately, Mildred Pierce became Crawford’s first starring role at Warners.

Cinematic prose vs. poetry

Mildred Pierce 1945 was adapted from the novel by James M. Cain, who also wrote Double Indemnity and The Postman Always Rings Twice. The adaptation was credited to Ranald MacDougall, though Catherine Turney (Of Human Bondage, A Stolen Life) and novelist William Faulkner were two among several uncredited writers who contributed to the project. Given what I’ve read of Faulkner’s melodramas, it’s no surprise this was right up his alley.

Mildred Pierce also has a fine soap-operatic score by Max Steiner, with just enough gravy in the right places to make the silliness entertain. The cinematography by Ernest Haller (who won an Oscar for Gone with the Wind) and the editing by David Weisbart are solid if prosaic.

The lack of a real “vision” in classic Hollywood films – such as Mildred Pierce – vis-à-vis the great European directors of the day, is stark. It defines the difference between cinematic prose and poetry.

In general, most of the films directed by Michael Curtiz, as with most studio directors, exhibit little distinctive style. The lone exceptions seem to have been in some quite deliciously Joseph L. Mankiewiczian dialogue afforded Jack Carson’s and Eve Arden’s characters.

Joan Crawford: The Ultimate Movie Star

Mildred Pierce 1945 has been well restored on the single-disc DVD from Warner Bros.

One side has the film, unfortunately sans audio commentary, while the other has a Joan Crawford film-trailer gallery and a terrific 90-minute documentary directed by Peter Fitzgerald and narrated by Anjelica Huston, Joan Crawford: The Ultimate Movie Star.

Fitzgerald’s documentary is so good it almost makes up for the DVD’s lack of commentary, as it features comments from Joan Crawford’s fellow actors, directors, and even her adopted daughter Christina Crawford, who went on to write the infamous tell-all memoir Mommie Dearest. Fortunately, Christina keeps her jealousy over her mother in check … most of the time.

Is Mildred Pierce 1945 a film noir?

Now, Mildred Pierce 1945 is often called a film noir, when it really is not.

After all, a film noir requires gritty realism, whereas Mildred Pierce lacks that quality. Film noir penetrates deeply into character; Mildred Pierce is propelled not by character exigencies, but by the Dumbest Possible Action and by having any real-world issues easily resolved. Curtiz’s film also relies on that old Hollywood standby: Style over substance.

But since Mildred Pierce is inherently melodramatic, the foregrounding of style over any deeper elements actually makes the film more enjoyable as a guilty pleasure.

And on that score, Mildred Pierce is terrific. It may not be a work filled with cosmic profundities and great performances for the ages, but it is loaded with charm and appeal, in addition to a who cares if it’s over the top? attitude that damns any claims of pretense.

Thus, Mildred Pierce is freed into being itself: That soap opera you guiltily love, but don’t want anyone else to know unless you tell first. Go ahead, now. It’s your turn!

Mildred Pierce (1945)

Director: Michael Curtiz.

Screenplay: Ranald MacDougall. (Uncredited contributors included Catherine Turney, Albert Maltz, and William Faulkner.)
From James M. Cain’s 1941 novel.

Cast: Joan Crawford. Ann Blyth. Zachary Scott. Jack Carson. Eve Arden. Bruce Bennett. Jo Ann Marlowe. Lee Patrick. Moroni Olsen. Veda Ann Borg.
Uncredited: Robert Arthur. Leah Baird. Joyce Compton. Marion Lessing. Philo McCullough. Butterfly McQueen. Paul Panzer. George Tobias.

Cinematography: Ernest Haller. Film Editing: David Weisbart. Music: Max Steiner. Art Direction: Anton Grot. Producer: Jerry Wald.

Mildred Pierce 1945 Movie Review: ‘Terrific’ Crawford in … Film Noir or Melodrama?” review text © Dan Schneider; image captions & brief summary © Alt Film Guide.

Mildred Pierce 1945 Movie Review: ‘Terrific’ Crawford in … Film Noir or Melodrama?” is a condensed/revised version of Dan Schneider’s original text found here.

Recommended articles

If you liked “Mildred Pierce 1945 Movie Review: ‘Terrific’ Crawford in … Film Noir or Melodrama?” check out:

Mildred Pierce 1945 cast and crew information via the AFI Catalog website and other sources.

Zachary Scott, Ann Blyth, and Joan Crawford Mildred Pierce 1945 images: Warner Bros.

Mildred Pierce 1945 Movie Review: ‘Terrific’ Crawford in … Film Noir or Melodrama?” last updated in March 2021.


You may also like

Leave a Comment

*IMPORTANT*: By using this form you agree with Alt Film Guide's storage and handling of your data (e.g., your IP address). Make sure your comment adds something relevant to the discussion: Feel free to disagree with us, but *thoughtfulness* and *at least a modicum of sanity* are imperative. Abusive, inflammatory, spammy/self-promotional, baseless (spreading mis- or disinformation), and just plain deranged comments will be zapped, and, if we deem appropriate, reported. Lastly, links found in submitted comments will generally be deleted.


JohnM -

I LOVE Joan Crawford and I LOVE “Mildred Pierce.” If ever an actress was made to play a role, that was Joan as Mildred. Sorry, Kate Winslet.

Lola Jordan -

With respect to Mr. Schneider, Mildred is a film noir, not a soapy melodrama with a camp treasure trove so chock full, it still delights today. To prove it’s worthiness, the recent HBO remake with Kate Winslett made us all long for Crawford and Curtiz again. Ann Blythe, the perfect Veda, as all cast were perfection in their roles. I can’t see why Mr. Schneider objected to Mildred luring the police to the beach house when that was Mildred’s ultimate sacrifice to Veda, to take the rap for her. Perfectly understandable for Mildred. I like to see this every once in a while just to hear Mildred say “I never saw you shrink from a $50 just because it smelled of grease.”


This website uses cookies to improve your experience. If you continue browsing, that means you've accepted our Terms of Use/use of cookies. You may also click on the Accept button on the right to make this notice disappear. AcceptRead More