HomeMovie ReviewsNicholas and Alexandra Movie: Visually Grandiose But Dramatically Stunted Historical Drama

Nicholas and Alexandra Movie: Visually Grandiose But Dramatically Stunted Historical Drama

Nicholas and Alexandra movie: Producer Sam Spiegel and director Franklin J. Schaffner’s 1971 historical spectacle is a visually lush but dramatically barren account of the fate of the last of the Romanovs. (Pictured: Michael Jayston and Janet Suzman in Nicholas and Alexandra.)
  • Nicholas and Alexandra (1971) movie review: Released six years after David Lean’s Russian Revolution-set blockbuster Doctor Zhivago, producer Sam Spiegel, director Franklin J. Schaffner, and screenwriter James Goldman’s opulent historical spectacle Nicholas and Alexandra is an old-fashioned feast for the eyes – one whose inherent drama is crippled by an array of mannered, artificial performances, and by Schaffner and Goldman’s graceless handling of the material.
  • Two notable exceptions in Nicholas and Alexandra’s hammy acting department: Michael Jayston as the troubled Tsar Nicholas II and Irene Worth as the commanding Queen Mother Marie Fedorovna.

Nicholas and Alexandra movie: Sam Spiegel & Franklin J. Schaffner’s opulent historical spectacle lacks emotional core

A Sam Spiegel (The African Queen, Lawrence of Arabia) production directed by Academy Award winner Franklin J. Schaffner (Patton, 1970), the Imperial Russia-set Nicholas and Alexandra is surely one of the most sumptuous movies ever made.

Production designer John Box’s palatial sets, Yvonne Blake and Antonio Castillo’s elaborate costumes, Richard Rodney Bennett’s lush musical score, and frequent David Lean collaborator Freddie Young’s richly textured cinematography provide the perfect period atmosphere for this historical epic about the last of the Romanovs.

Missing, however, is a screenplay featuring true-to-life dialogue instead of bombast, and a directorial hand highlighting the story’s inherent drama instead of soapy histrionics.

Problem-plagued imperial family

Nicholas and Alexandra begins in the early 1900s, when Tsar Nicholas II (Michael Jayston), the current ruling member of the House of Romanov, finally becomes the father of a boy. Shortly thereafter, he and his wife, the German-born Empress Alexandra (Best Actress Academy Award nominee Janet Suzman[1]), have their happiness crushed when they discover that their infant son is a hemophiliac.

In addition to his family issues, the tsar must deal with popular discontent over a long-running war against Japan for control of the Korean peninsula and with social disturbances caused by a wrecked economy and a lack of democratic institutions. In the meantime, the empress soothes her pain with the assistance of the mystic Grigori Rasputin (Tom Baker), who seems to have mysterious powers that keep her frail son alive.

Through the guidance of his advisors, the gentle but narrow-minded tsar grudgingly opens up the semi-feudal Russian political system. But it’s too little, too late. Worsening matters, an ill-fated decision to send troops to the western border leads to a declaration of war from Germany and the start of World War I.

As the Russian economy collapses, social and political chaos ensues. Inevitably, the Romanov family ends up swept into the flames of the revolution.

Old-fashioned mix of history lesson + melodrama

As a result of Franklin J. Schaffner’s old-fashioned direction – Nicholas and Alexandra wouldn’t have looked too out of place in the mid-1950s, alongside Henry Koster’s Désirée and King Vidor’s War and Peace – and James Goldman’s part-history lesson, part-daytime soap screenplay, most of the Nicholas and Alexandra cast perform their roles instead of living them out.

Royal National Theatre member Tom Baker’s absurdly mannered Rasputin is a case in point; and so is Royal Shakespeare Company star Janet Suzman’s grand but superficial Alexandra – who, like everyone in Imperial Russia, from peasants to foreign-born empresses, speaks flawlessly posh English.

Laurence Olivier (Best Actor Oscar winner for Hamlet, 1948), for his part, is so over the top as the former prime minister of Russia, Count Sergei Witte, that his climactic “the end is near” speech comes across as parody, while scenes featuring Lenin (Michael Bryant), Trotsky (Brian Cox), and most other figures of the period feel unpalatably phony.

Memorable Michael Jayston & imposing Irene Worth

On the positive side, the stage-trained Michael Jayston, at the time with only two big-screen supporting roles to his credit (A Midsummer Night’s Dream, 1968; Cromwell, 1970), actually fares better than most of Nicholas and Alexandra’s movie-veteran cast members.

Aside from a few theatrical moments, Jayston – a dead ringer for Nicholas II – ably conveys the tsar’s failings as well as his strengths in a believable and at times poignant manner.

But it’s Nebraska-born Broadway actress Irene Worth who, with her commanding presence as the Danish-born Queen Mother Marie Fedorovna, manages to steal every scene in which she appears.

Watching Worth’s no-nonsense elder queen, one realizes that had she been the ruler of all Russias in 1917, there would have been no revolution. No one would have dared.

Nicholas and Alexandra (1971) with Janet Suzman and Michael Jayston: The last of the Romanovs discover that power, no matter how absolute, can be fleeting. The costly historical epic received six Oscar nods, including Best Picture; it topped two categories: Best Art Direction and Costume Design.

Dramatically redemptive horror

A less conventional – and less artificial – approach to the complex, tragic demise of Imperial Russia’s Romanov family could have turned Nicholas and Alexandra into a masterful historical drama.

As it stands, Sam Spiegel and Franklin J. Schaffner’s costly epic feels like an overlong soap opera, made watchable by a couple of solid performances and superlative production values.

Having said that, one must admit that Nicholas and Alexandra is partially redeemed at the end. For despite the absence of the surprise element, the ultimate fate of the last of the Romanovs is no less horrifying.

Nicholas and Alexandra (1971)

Director: Franklin J. Schaffner.

Screenplay: James Goldman. Additional dialogue by Edward Bond.
From Robert K. Massie’s 1967 book Nicholas and Alexandra: An Intimate Account of the Last of the Romanovs and the Fall of Imperial Russia.

Cast: Michael Jayston. Janet Suzman. Irene Worth. Laurence Olivier. Tom Baker. Harry Andrews. Michael Bryant. Maurice Denham. Jack Hawkins. Ian Holm. John McEnery. Eric Porter. Michael Redgrave. Alan Webb. Curd Jürgens. Lynne Frederick. Fiona Fullerton. Katherine Schofield. Roderic Nobel. Timothy West. John Hallam. John Wood. Guy Rolfe. Alexander Knox. Candace Glendenning. Ania Marson. Vivian Pickles. Brian Cox. Jean-Claude Drouot. James Hazeldine. Stephen Greif. Roy Dotrice. Martin Potter. Julian Glover. John Shrapnel. Ralph Truman. George Rigaud. Richard Warwick. John Forbes-Robertson.
Uncredited: Robin Askwith. (Although listed in a number of sources, Jeremy Brett’s uncredited appearance is unconfirmed.)

Cinematography: Freddie Young. Film Editing: Ernest Walter. Music: Richard Rodney Bennett. Production Design: John Box. Producer: Sam Spiegel.


Nicholas and Alexandra Movie” notes

Earlier casting & director possibilities

[1] For the role of Alexandra (granddaughter of the United Kingdom’s Queen Victoria, believed to be a carrier of the hemophilia B trait), Sam Spiegel had wanted either Vanessa Redgrave or Katharine Hepburn, the latter a recent Best Actress Oscar co-winner for her performance as Eleanor of Aquitaine in Anthony Harvey’s 1968 historical drama The Lion in Winter, based on James Goldman’s play.

Planet of the Apes and Patton director Franklin J. Schaffner stepped in to handle Nicholas and Alexandra after Anthony Harvey, two-time Best Director Oscar winner George Stevens (A Place in the Sun, 1951; Giant, 1956), and Charles Jarrott (Anne of the Thousand Days, Mary Queen of Scots) bowed out reportedly due to scheduling conflicts.

Others considered for the job included Joseph L. Mankiewicz, Ken Russell, Lindsay Anderson, and John Boorman.

Also of note, Tom Baker replaced Peter O’Toole as Rasputin (a role Yul Brynner is supposed to have campaigned for), while Rex Harrison had been a possibility as Count Witte.


Recommended articles

If you liked “Nicholas and Alexandra Movie: Visually Grandiose But Dramatically Stunted Historical Drama,” check out:


Nicholas and Alexandra movie cast and crew information via the AFI Catalog website and other sources.

Michael Jayston and Janet Suzman Nicholas and Alexandra images: Columbia Pictures.

Nicholas and Alexandra Movie: Visually Grandiose But Dramatically Stunted Historical Drama” last updated in December 2020.

1 comment

You may also like

Leave a Comment

*IMPORTANT*: By using this form you agree with Alt Film Guide's storage and handling of your data (e.g., your IP address). Make sure your comment adds something relevant to the discussion: Feel free to disagree with us, but *thoughtfulness* and *at least a modicum of sanity* are imperative. Abusive, inflammatory, spammy/self-promotional, baseless (spreading mis- or disinformation), and just plain deranged comments will be zapped, and, if we deem appropriate, reported. Lastly, links found in submitted comments will generally be deleted.

1 comment

Gunnar -

Decades later, this film still stands the test of time. Beautifully crafted, great sets and costumes, GOOD acting, and most certainly NOT without an “emotional core”. One gets a sense of who the couple was, of their love for one another, of their concerns for Russia. Despite their power and prestige, you get to LIKE them, if not for their good points, then for their human frailties. They and their children did not deserve to die as they did. That too elicits human empathy in viewers. A good film isn’t just about actors and sets, it’s also about audience response. A shame that the reviewer could only experience what was in HIS mind.

Reply

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. If you continue browsing, that means you've accepted our Terms of Use/use of cookies. You may also click on the Accept button on the right to make this notice disappear. AcceptRead More