Oscar Comebacks: Julie Christie & Henry Fonda + Roman Polanski

by Alt Film Guide
Roman Polanski The Pianist Adrien Brody
Oscar comebacks: Adrien Brody in Roman Polanski's The Pianist.

Generally speaking, most actors, actresses, and directors either get that once-in-a-lifetime Academy Award nomination, or, if they're lucky, a couple or a handful of nods within a period of two to fifteen years. There are a number of exceptions to that rule, of course, but in the Academy Awards' 83-year history very few performers and directors – 28 of them, to be exact – have received Oscar nominations after a gap of 20 years or more in their respective categories, i.e., actors/acting categories; directors/Best Direction category.

On the next page (please see link below) you'll find a complete list of Oscar's major “comebacks” – actors and/or directors who had to wait two decades or longer in-between nominations. Among those are record-holder Henry Fonda (41 years), John Huston, Julie Christie, Roman Polanski, Mickey Rooney, Alan Arkin, Lynn Redgrave, and Jeff Bridges.

Below is a list of 28 actors and directors who had to wait 20 years or more for the next Academy Award nomination in their respective categories, i.e., actors/acting categories; directors/Best Direction category. That's why Henry Fonda is listed first with a 41-year gap between nominations, even though he was shortlisted for the 1957 Academy Awards as one of the producers of Best Picture nominee 12 Angry Men.

Also, unless otherwise noted, the acting nominations are for leading roles. Years in bold represent Oscar victories.

41 years between nominations

Henry Fonda (1940, The Grapes of Wrath; 1981, On Golden Pond)

38

Helen Hayes (1931-32, The Sin of Madelon Claudet; 1970, supporting, Airport)

Jack Palance (1953, supporting, Shane; 1991, supporting, City Slickers)

Alan Arkin (1968, The Heart Is a Lonely Hunter; 2006, supporting, Little Miss Sunshine)

35

Ralph Richardson (1949, supporting, The Heiress; 1984, supporting, Greystoke: The Legend of Tarzan, Lord of the Apes)

33

John Huston (director) (1952, Moulin Rouge; 1985, Prizzi's Honor)

32

Lynn Redgrave (1966, Georgy Girl [right, with Alan Bates]; 1998, supporting, Gods and Monsters)

28

Paul Scofield (1966, A Man for All Seasons; 1994, supporting, Quiz Show)

27

Richard Harris (1963, This Sporting Life; 1990, The Field)

26

James Whitmore (1949, supporting, Battleground; 1975, Give'em Hell, Harry!)

Julie Christie (1971, McCabe & Mrs. Miller; 1997, Afterglow)

24

Christopher Walken (1978, supporting, The Deer Hunter; 2002, supporting, Catch Me If You Can)

Peter O'Toole (1982, My Favorite Year; 2006, Venus)

23

Fay Bainter* (1938, White Banners, and 1938, supporting, Jezebel; 1961, supporting, The Children's Hour)

William Holden (1953, Stalag 17; 1976, Network)

Mickey Rooney (1956, supporting, The Bold and the Brave; 1979, supporting, The Black Stallion)

22

Charles Laughton (1935, Mutiny on the Bounty; 1957, Witness for the Prosecution)

Paul Muni (1937, The Life of Emile Zola; 1959, The Last Angry Man)

Roman Polanski (director) (1980, Tess; 2002, The Pianist)

21

Gladys Cooper (1943, supporting, The Song of Bernadette; 1964, supporting, My Fair Lady)

Jean Simmons (1948, supporting, Hamlet; 1969, The Happy Ending)

Richard Farnsworth (1978, supporting, Comes a Horseman; 1999, The Straight Story)

20

Gloria Swanson (1929-30, The Trespasser; 1950, Sunset Blvd. [right])

Wendy Hiller (1938, Pygmalion; 1958, supporting, Separate Tables)

John Wayne (1949, Sands of Iwo Jima; 1969, True Grit)

Joseph L. Mankiewicz (director) (1952, 5 Fingers; 1972, Sleuth)

Alec Guinness (1957, The Bridge on the River Kwai; 1977, supporting, Star Wars)

Ellen Burstyn (1980, Resurrection; 2000, Requiem for a Dream)

* Fay Bainter was nominated as both leading and supporting actress in 1938. She won in the latter category.

You may also like

Leave a Comment

IMPORTANT: By using this form you agree with the storage and handling of your data by Alt Film Guide. Also, *thoughtfulness* and *at least a modicum of sanity* are imperative. Abusive/bigoted, trollish/inflammatory, baseless (spreading misinformation, whether intentionally or not), spammy, and/or just plain deranged comments will be zapped. And finally, links found in submitted comments will generally be deleted.

2 comments

John -

John Huston really shouldn't count. While, yes, he had to wait 33 years for another Best Director nomination, he would receive a Best Supporting Actor nomination in 1963 for the Cardinal and Screenplay nominations in 1958 and 1975 for Heaven Knows Mr. Allison and The Man Who Would Be King, respectively.

Reply
Andre -

Thanks for pointing that out.
I should have made this clearer. Twenty-year gap or longer for nominations within acting/directing categories. I'll clarify that in the text itself.

Reply

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. If you continue browsing, that means you've accepted our Terms of Use/use of cookies. You may also click on the Accept button on the right to make this notice disappear. Accept Read More