Alt Film Guide
Classic movies. Gay movies. International cinema. Socially conscious & political cinema.
Home Classic Movies Robert Mitchum Movies: Ryan’s Daughter Cast Against Type

Robert Mitchum Movies: Ryan’s Daughter Cast Against Type

Robert Mitchum
Robert Mitchum ca. late 1940s.

Robert Mitchum movies The Yakuza & Ryan’s Daughter on TCM

Ramon Novarro biography Beyond Paradise

On Aug. 12, Turner Classic Movies’ “Summer Under the Stars” series is highlighting the career of Robert Mitchum. Two of the films being shown this evening are The Yakuza and Ryan’s Daughter. The former is one of the disappointingly few TCM premieres this month. (See TCM’s Robert Mitchum movie schedule further below.)

Despite his film noir background, Robert Mitchum was a somewhat unusual choice to star in The Yakuza (1975), a crime thriller set in the Japanese underworld. Ryan’s Daughter or no, Mitchum hadn’t been a box office draw in quite some time; in the mid-1970s, one would have expected a Warner Bros. release directed by Sydney Pollack – who had recently handled the likes of Jane Fonda, Barbra Streisand, and Robert Redford – to star someone like Jack Nicholson or Al Pacino or Dustin Hoffman. But Robert Mitchum it was.

In fact, as found in Lee Server’s Robert Mitchum: “Baby, I Don’t Care,” Mitchum – with director approval – was cast after Lee Marvin turned down the role and before Pollack was hired. Robert Aldrich was supposed to handle the proceedings (he and Marvin had worked together on The Dirty Dozen), but Mitchum nixed the idea.* He selected the Jeremiah Johnson and The Way We Were director instead.

Four-time Japanese Academy Award winner Ken Takakura, who has been described as the Japanese Humphrey Bogart, was Mitchum’s co-star, while Eiji Okada, Emmanuelle Riva’s romantic interest in Alain Resnais’ Hiroshima Mon Amour (1959) and the star of Hiroshi Teshigahara’s Woman in the Dunes (1964), landed a supporting role.

‘Kirk Douglas-san’

As mentioned in the Mitchum biography, upon his arrival in Japan in January 1974 the Hollywood star held a small press conference during which he told local journalists, “Remember Pearl Harbor.”

It’s unclear whether the Japanese journalists found that humorous or if they replied back, “Remember Hiroshima and Nagasaki.” (Seventy years ago earlier this month.)

Mitchum also threw tantrums during the shoot – “I want out. I really want out. Perhaps the only way they will believe me is if I pack my bags and get out of here tomorrow. … Greta Garbo did it. …” – and had to deal with autograph hunters calling him “Kirk Douglas-san.”†

With a screenplay by Paul Schrader (Taxi Driver) and Yakuza-experienced Leonard Schrader (Kiss of the Spider Woman), later revised by credited co-screenwriter Robert Towne (Chinatown), The Yakuza should have been if not a box office hit, then at least a critically acclaimed effort.

At the time of its release, Pollack’s film was neither. In later years, The Yakuza has developed a cult following, though it remains little known outside the circle of gangster film aficionados.

About working with Robert Mitchum, Sydney Pollack would later say: “I found him to be like a very, very powerful and lazy horse. He wants to walk as slow as possible and get away with doing as little as possible. You used to really have to push him. He won’t offer the full emotional nature of a performance, at least he didn’t for me, until you went after him a little bit.”

* According to several online sources (I was unable to trace their original source), Robert Mitchum didn’t want to work with Robert Aldrich again, as he remembered his experience with the director during the making of The Angry Hills (1959). Besides The Dirty Dozen, Aldrich is best known for the Bette Davis-Joan Crawford star vehicle What Ever Happened to Baby Jane?.

† Robert Mitchum and Sydney Pollack quotes, “Kirk Douglas-san” via Robert Mitchum: “Baby, I Don’t Care.” Server’s sources for these two particular bits of information aren’t explicitly divulged in the book, but in that segment he quotes extensively The Yakuza assistant director Michael Moore.

Robert Mitchum Ryan’s Daughter Sarah MilesRobert Mitchum in ‘Ryan’s Daughter’ with Sarah Miles.

‘Ryan’s Daughter’

Back in the 1940s and early 1950s, David Lean was known for several first-rate intimate dramas – e.g., This Happy Breed, Brief Encounter, The Passionate Friends, Hobson’s Choice – featuring top-notch performances by the likes of Ann Todd (Lean’s wife from 1949-1957), Celia Johnson, Claude Rains, Charles Laughton, and John Mills. What a difference a multiple Oscar winner like The Bridge on the River Kwai (1957) makes.

Following that hugely successful, big-budget Anglo-American release, Lean never looked back. First, there was the even more mammoth Lawrence of Arabia (1962) and then the leviathanesque Doctor Zhivago (1965); both were enormous international hits.

‘Madame Bovary’ reboot

Next in line was an intimate drama – a Madame Bovary reboot written by Robert Bolt (Lawrence of Arabia, A Man for All Seasons) – filmed as if it were another bloated epic: Ryan’s Daughter (1970).

Lean’s ham-fisted approach and the film’s inordinate length are both major handicaps to the delicate, complex story about love, betrayal, and social pressure in British-occupied Ireland at the time of World War I. Admittedly, these issues were hardly new in a David Lean film as they had also plagued Doctor Zhivago and, to a lesser extent, Lawrence of Arabia – both of which earned multiple Academy Award nominations, including Best Picture and Best Director. Lawrence of Arabia, in fact, came out on top in both categories in addition to five others, and is considered by many one of the greatest movies ever made.

Sarah Miles, Robert Mitchum at their best

Ryan’s Daughter, for its part, is saved from a fate worse than death by a solid second half and a first-rate cast:

  • Robert Bolt’s wife Sarah Miles, one of the most remarkable (and most underused) British actresses of the ’60s (The Servant, Blow-Up), delivers what may well be the most complex performance of her career. Miles was nominated for the Best Actress Oscar, but lost to Glenda Jackson in Ken Russell’s Women in Love.
  • Robert Mitchum (instead of original choice Paul Scofield), whom I generally find much more effective as “soft” or “weak” men than as cynical tough guys. Hired for $870,000, Mitchum plays the older, sedate husband of Sarah Miles, who has been having an affair with young and handsome British soldier Christopher Jones. I should add that the film’s director and its male lead did not get along. And that Mitchum’s behavior toward Sarah Miles – as described in one of her autobiographies – could have gotten him sued for sexual harassment today. (Widespread rumors notwithstanding, Miles has asserted she did not have an affair with her co-star.)
  • Veteran John Mills, who had previously worked with Lean in In Which We Serve (1942), This Happy Breed (1944), Great Expectations (1946) and Hobson’s Choice (1954). Mills fully deserved his Best Supporting Actor Oscar for his portrayal of the local “village idiot” – a performance some find offensive.

Christopher Jones looks the part of the handsome British officer (written for Marlon Brando), but apparently didn’t sound it; his voice was dubbed by Stanley Holloway’s son, Julian Holloway – who possibly would have had to dub Brando as well.

In later years, Jones blamed his less than effective performance on his personal life, claiming he was having an affair with Sharon Tate, who was going to leave Roman Polanski for him. Tate was murdered in Aug. 1969, while Ryan’s Daughter was in production.

Although a box office success in the U.K. and the U.S., the costly Ryan’s Daughter had a tough time earning its money back. The film won only two Oscars: John Mills’ and Best Cinematography for Freddie Young.

Besides Sarah Miles’, its only other nomination was for Best Sound.

Six films, five Best Director Oscar nods

David Lean’s last six films earned him five Best Director Academy Award nominations. Two of these resulted in victories: The Bridge on the River Kwai, Lawrence of Arabia. The one movie for which Lean was bypassed by the Academy’s Directors Branch? Ryan’s Daughter.

The five nominees that year, by the way, were a mix of traditional and unconventional filmmakers:

For the record, David Lean’s three other latter-career Best Director Oscar nominations were for the aforementioned Doctor Zhivago, Summertime (1955), and, my favorite among his psychological epics, A Passage to India (1984).

Lean had been previously nominated in that category for Brief Encounter (1946) and Great Expectations (1947).

Robert Mitchum Ryan’s DaughterRobert Mitchum in ‘Ryan’s Daughter.’

Robert Mitchum movies: TCM schedule (PT)

3:00 AM TILL THE END OF TIME (1946). Director: Edward Dmytryk. Cast: Dorothy McGuire. Guy Madison. Robert Mitchum. B&W. 105 mins.

5:00 AM MY FORBIDDEN PAST (1951). Director: Robert Stevenson. Cast: Robert Mitchum. Ava Gardner. Melvyn Douglas. B&W. 70 mins.

6:15 AM THE SUNDOWNERS (1960). Director: Fred Zinnemann. Cast: Deborah Kerr. Robert Mitchum. Peter Ustinov. Michael Anderson Jr. Glynis Johns. Color. 133 mins. Letterbox Format.

8:45 AM RACHEL AND THE STRANGER (1948). Director: Norman Foster. Cast: Loretta Young. William Holden. Robert Mitchum. B&W. 79 mins.

10:15 AM BLOOD ON THE MOON (1948). Director: Robert Wise. Cast: Robert Mitchum. Barbara Bel Geddes. Robert Preston. B&W. 88 mins.

11:45 AM THE LUSTY MEN (1952). Director: Nicholas Ray. Cast: Susan Hayward. Robert Mitchum. Arthur Kennedy. Arthur Hunnicutt. Frank Faylen. Walter Coy. Carol Nugent. Maria Hart. Lorna Thayer. Jimmie Dodd. Eleanor Todd. Uncredited: Glenn Strange. Lane Chandler. B&W. 113 mins.

1:45 PM THE HUNTERS (1958). Director: Dick Powell. Cast: Robert Mitchum. Robert Wagner. Richard Egan. May Britt. Lee Phillips. John Gabriel. Stacy Harris. Victor Sen Yung. Candace Lee. Color. 108 mins. Letterbox Format.

3:45 PM THE DICK CAVETT SHOW: ROBERT MITCHUM (1971). Robert Mitchum interview originally aired on April 29, 1971. Color. 66 mins.

5:00 PM HOME FROM THE HILL (1960). Director: Vincente Minnelli. Cast: Robert Mitchum. Eleanor Parker. George Peppard. George Hamilton. Everett Sloane. Luana Patten. Anne Seymour. Constance Ford. Ken Renard. Ray Teal. Uncredited: Bess Flowers. Bill Hickman. Denver Pyle. Dub Taylor. Guinn ‘Big Boy’ Williams. Color. 150 mins. Letterbox Format.

7:45 PM THUNDER ROAD (1958). Director: Arthur Ripley. Cast: Robert Mitchum. Gene Barry. Jacques Aubochon. B&W. 93 mins. Letterbox Format.

9:30 PM THE YAKUZA (1975). Director: Sydney Pollack. Cast: Robert Mitchum. Ken Takakura. Brian Keith. Eiji Okada. Color. 112 mins. Letterbox Format.

11:30 PM RYAN’S DAUGHTER (1970). Director: David Lean. Cast: Robert Mitchum. Sarah Miles. Christopher Jones. Trevor Howard. John Mills. Leo McKern. Color. 206 mins. Letterbox Format.


Robert Mitchum movie schedule via the TCM website.

Robert Mitchum movies’ cast info via the IMDb.

Robert Mitchum image via Silver Screen Suppers.

Robert Mitchum Ryan’s Daughter image: Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer, via the Roger Ebert website.

Recommended for You

Leave a Comment

*IMPORTANT*: By using this form you agree with Alt Film Guide's storage and handling of your data (e.g., your IP address). Make sure your comment adds something relevant to the discussion: Feel free to disagree with us and write your own movie commentaries, but *thoughtfulness* and *at least a modicum of sanity* are imperative. Abusive, inflammatory, spammy/self-promotional, baseless (spreading mis- or disinformation), and just plain deranged comments will be zapped. Lastly, links found in submitted comments will generally be deleted.

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. If you continue browsing, that means you've accepted our Terms of Use/use of cookies. You may also click on the Accept button on the right to make this notice disappear. Accept Read More