Love & mortality + the space in between: ‘Orpheus’ & ‘A Matter of Life and Death / Stairway to Heaven’
(See previous post: “Christmas Films: Atypical Macho John Travolta + Whacked Sandra Dee Topples Family Tree.”) The last two entries in Turner Classic Movies’ Dec. 19–20 line-up are two post-World War II European fantasies tackling the issues of human love and mortality: Jean Cocteau’s French fantasy Orpheus / Orphée and Michael Powell and Emeric Pressburger’s British fantasy A Matter of Life and Death / Stairway to Heaven.
The similarities pretty much end there. The former was made for adults; the latter, notwithstanding its undeniable qualities, was made with an eye on the mainstream American market.
Love = Death
A Christmas film for the poetically inclined, Cocteau’s entrancing, visually arresting Orpheus / Orphée (1950) stars Jean Marais in the title role – a handsome, modern-day Parisian poet who falls in love with Death. If that weren’t all, it looks like the feeling is reciprocal.
No one in their right mind should watch Orpheus expecting a happy ending. I mean, not even a certified Hollywood product like Mitchell Leisen’s Death Takes a Holiday (1934), in which Death (Fredric March) falls head over heels for a pretty young thing (Evelyn Venable), dared to give its two lovebirds a happy hereafter.
Instead, you should expect to be mesmerized by Orpheus’ black-and-white cinematography, courtesy of veteran Nicolas Hayer (Le Corbeau, La Chartreuse de Parme); by Jean d’Eaubonne’s production design and Albert Volper’s set decoration; and the music of Georges Auric (the 1946 Cannes Film Festival’s Best Musical Score winner for La Symphonie Pastorale).
Death becomes her: Magnificent Maria Casarès
As a plus, Orpheus’ trio of blond performers are all great to look at: leading man Jean Marais; Jean Cocteau’s latest protégé, Edouard Dhermitte, in a supporting role as the poet Cégeste, the young protégé of a mysterious princess; and Marie Déa (Les Visiteurs du Soir, Secrets) as Orpheus’ wife, the (at least for a while) ill-fated Eurydice.
Yet Orpheus truly belongs to the raven-haired Maria Casarès (Children of Paradise, Les dames du Bois de Boulogne), who, in coolly passionate splendor, brings to life The Princess and her otherworldly self, Death. In fact, Casarès work in Orpheus remains one – or rather, two? – of the greatest, most indelible portrayals in film history.
‘Stairway to Heaven’ & U.K./U.S. relations: That space in between + celestial flag-waving
Filled with good intentions and eager to ensure that its post-war Anglo-American audience wouldn’t give up hope for a better world, Michael Powell and Emeric Pressburger’s A Matter of Life and Death / Stairway to Heaven (1946) revolves around a man who should be dead but isn’t quite.
That’s David Niven’s fearless all-British pilot, who finds himself both back in England and in that space in between also inhabited by Robert Montgomery in Alexander Hall’s Here Comes Mr. Jordan (1941) and James Stewart in Frank Capra’s It’s a Wonderful Life (1946).
Should the pilot be allowed to go on living? Or should he be dragged up the steps of that seemingly endless Stairway to Heaven?
There is much to recommend this (mostly) Technicolor fantasy. Having said that, Stairway to Heaven should have been a good 20 minutes shorter and a lot less politically didactic.
Like Orpheus, this Powell & Pressburger collaboration deals not only with its titular topics but also with the complex question of love – albeit in a less somber, less ethereal, and more simple-minded manner than the Cocteau film.
That’s possibly because the filmmakers’ chief concern – besides American moviegoers’ dollars – was the more mundane matter of flag-waving, which, inevitably, is handled with the subtlety of an elephant stampede.
Yesterday’s worst enemy…
At one point, celestial barristers Raymond Massey and Roger Livesey, hardly the most understated of actors, take it upon themselves to engage in an endless argument about the heavenly ordained relationship between the United Kingdom and the United States – two nations that, long before their deified WWII alliance, had fought three wars against each other in the preceding two centuries.
Besides the verbose Massey and Livesey, Stairway to Heaven features an ineffectual David Niven (at his best in non-romantic roles – e.g., Around the World in 80 Days, Separate Tables); the lovely – and lovingly photographed – Kim Hunter (Best Supporting Actress Oscar winner for A Streetcar Named Desire, 1951) as the pilot’s American love interest (instead of the originally considered Betty Field); and, as a fey heavenly Conductor, a surprisingly effective Marius Goring (The Red Shoes, Odette).
In sum, political didacticism or no, Stairway to Heaven is not to be missed.
Below is the Turner Classic Movies schedule featuring Orpheus and Stairway to Heaven.
TCM Christmas films on Dec. 19: From ‘Grease’ ‘ to ‘Stairway to Heaven’
5:00 p.m. Grease (1978). Cast: John Travolta. Olivia Newton-John. Stockard Channing. Jeff Conaway. Barry Pearl. Michael Tucci. Kelly Ward. Didi Conn. Annette Charles. Frankie Avalon. Joan Blondell. Eve Arden. Alice Ghostley. Sid Caesar. Dody Goodman. Lorenzo Lamas. Director: Randal Kleiser. Color. 110 mins.
7:00 p.m. A Summer Place (1959). Cast: Richard Egan. Dorothy McGuire. Sandra Dee. Troy Donahue. Arthur Kennedy. Constance Ford. Beulah Bondi. Jack Richardson. Martin Eric. Uncredited: Ann Doran. Director: Delmer Daves. Color. 130 mins.
9:15 p.m. The King of Kings (1927). Cast:H.B. Warner. Dorothy Cumming. Ernest Torrence. Joseph Schildkraut. Jacqueline Logan. James Neill. Joseph Striker. Robert Edeson. Rudolph Schildkraut. Sam De Grasse. Victor Varconi. Casson Ferguson. Montagu Love. William Boyd. Julia Faye. Theodore Kosloff. Kenneth Thomson. George Siegmann. Micky Moore. May Robson. Dot Farley. Sôjin Kamiyama (as Sojin). Director:Cecil B. DeMille. B&W. 157 mins.
12:00 a.m. Orpheus / Orphée (1949). Cast: Jean Marais. Marie Déa. Maria Casarès. Edouard Dermithe (a.k.a. Édouard Dermit & Edouard Dhermitte). François Périer. Henri Crémieux. Juliette Greco. Roger Blin. Uncredited: Jean-Pierre Melville. Narrator: Jean Cocteau. Director: Jean Cocteau. B&W. 95 mins.
1:45 a.m. A Matter of Life and Death / Stairway to Heaven (1946). Cast: David Niven. Kim Hunter. Roger Livesey. Raymond Massey. Marius Goring. Robert Coote. Kathleen Byron. Richard Attenborough. Bonar Colleano. Uncredited: Lois Maxwell. Director: Michael Powell & Emeric Pressburger. Color. 104 mins.
More Christmas movies
Below is a list of Alt Film Guide posts about Christmas movies for all seasons:
- TCM’s Christmas movies: From Bette Davis & Gary Cooper to Black Christmas and Santa Claus Conquers the Martians.
- What Do Quakers Believe?Friendly Persuasion & the Lure of Violence + War.
- Turner Classic‘s Dysfunctional-Family-Friendly Christmas cheer.
- War on Christmas movies.
- Classic Christmas Movies: Remember the Night Returns + Largely Forgotten Oscar Nominee on TCM.
- Christmas Cheer: Andy Hardy & Rediscovering Sherlock Holmes Actor + One of Best Woody Allen Movies.
- The Day After Christmas: Lilli Palmer + Gay Icon Silent Treatment & 1 of Greatest “Conservative” Movies Ever?
Princess = Death?
 Watching Orpheus, it seems pretty obvious that Maria Casarès’ Princess and Death are one and the same. Jean Cocteau, as quoted in The Art of Cinema, apparently disagrees:
“Among the misconceptions which have been written about Orphée, I still see Heurtebise* described as an angel and the Princess as Death.
In the film, there is no Death and no angel. There can be none. Heurtebise is a young Death serving in one of the numerous sub-orders of Death, and the Princess is no more Death than an air hostess is an angel.
I never touch on dogmas. The region that I depict is a border on life, a no man’s land where one hovers between life and death.”
* François Périer plays Heurtebise, the Princess’ chauffeur/Death’s attendant who falls in love with Eurydice.
Featuring various Jean Cocteau essays, The Art of Cinema was edited by André Bernard and Claude Gauteur.
Black and white in color
A Matter of Life and Death / Stairway to Heaven was shot in color by the masterful Jack Cardiff.
The “in-between/is this heaven?” scenes, however, were, according to the credits, “dye-monochrome processed.” That gave them an unusual black-and-white look.
Sharing the blame
In all fairness, Roger Livesey is equally to blame, along with the Powell and Pressburger directing/screenwriting duo.
Turner Classic Movies schedule via the TCM website.
Grease, A Summer Place, The King of Kings, Orpheus / Orphée, and A Matter of Life and Death / Stairway to Heaven cast info via the IMDb.
Jean Marais and Maria Casarès Orpheus / Orphée images: DisCina.
Kim Hunter and David Niven A Matter of Life and Death / Stairway to Heaven image: Eagle-Lion Films.
“Stairway to Heaven & Orpheus: Two Radically Different Fantasies Tackle That Mysterious Space in Between” last updated in May 2018.