Alt Film Guide
Classic movies. Gay movies. International cinema. Socially conscious & political cinema.
Home Film ArticlesMovie Reviews Star Trek Beyond (Movie 2016): Problematic Gay Sulu

Star Trek Beyond (Movie 2016): Problematic Gay Sulu

Star Trek Beyond Chris PineStar Trek Beyond movie with Chris Pine as Captain Kirk.
  • Star Trek Beyond (movie 2016) review: Despite its not inconsiderable flaws – including some messy action sequences – Justin Lin’s sci-fi adventure is the best entry to date in the new Star Trek movie series because it doesn’t try as hard as its two predecessors. But John Cho’s gay Sulu is a problem.
  • Star Trek Beyond received one Academy Award nomination: Best Achievement in Makeup and Hairstyling (Joel Harlow & Richard Alonzo).

Star Trek Beyond (movie 2016) review: Big-screen franchise needs to boldly go where J.J. Abrams has never gone before

Ramon Novarro biography Beyond Paradise

We’re never told what “beyond” refers to in Star Trek Beyond, the 13th film in the venerated sci-fi series. But here’s a theory: If the franchise is to regain its footing after the tepid returns of Star Trek Into Darkness, it will have to move beyond J.J. Abrams, the writer/director who used his brand of copycat magic to relaunch the series in 2009.

In our reboot era, Abrams has got the canny ability to provide older audiences with enough familiarity to keep them under the tent while giving new audiences enough youthful verve so they don’t feel the franchise isn’t for them. If you think that’s not worth something, see Star Wars: The Force Awakens, where he elevated the concept to the level of pop art.

It’s a strength Abrams overplayed in Star Trek Into Darkness, a noisy contraption that fancied itself a clever nod to series highpoint Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan, but was really a collection of winking allusions that overlooked what the 1982 classic was actually about: Coming to terms with mortality.

For Star Trek Beyond, Abrams is out, replaced by Justin Lin, who’s known for a film series that only truly faced the issue of mortality when one of its stars, Paul Walker, died in real life. Nevertheless, one cannot fault Paramount for hiring the visual impresario who turned the Fast and Furious movies into a global money machine.

Star Trek Beyond plot: Lotsa running & crashing

Star Trek Beyond is the moment when the underperforming series either achieves escape velocity or permanently wanders the franchise firmament lamenting its fate as a middleweight contender. Lin is the key to this equation; a name brand director with a core group of young, motivated fans who’ll line up to see multi-culti casts run around and crash into things.

There’s lots of running and crashing in Star Trek Beyond, yet there’s a modesty and personality here not seen in the previous two films. The script by Simon Pegg (who reprises his role as Montgomery Scott, a.k.a. Scotty) and Doug Jung makes the refreshing choice of setting most of the action on a planet, as opposed to the claustrophobic, labyrinthine corridors of the Enterprise.

In fact, the ship, which Lin shoots from unique and exciting angles, doesn’t even make it past the first 30 minutes. A gargantuan swarm of small, metallic “bees” pummel the Enterprise until it’s sliced into pieces, the saucer section crashing into the planet Altamid. Stranded, the crew is separated into smaller groups – an excellent opportunity, mostly wasted, for Lin to explore these characters.

An injured Spock (Zachary Quinto, reminding us how much Leonard Nimoy brought to the role) admits to Bones (Karl Urban, more constipated scowling) that he wants to oversee the development of New Vulcan. It’s a weightless threat since we know he’s not going to leave Kirk (Chris Pine, making the role his own), any more than Kirk is going to accept the vice admiral position he’s offered at the outset.

Star Trek Beyond 2016 Anton YelchinStar Trek Beyond with Anton Yelchin as Chekov: The movie is dedicated to Yelchin, who died at age 27 in a freak accident in June 2016, and to the original Spock, Leonard Nimoy, who died in February 2015.

Kirk vs. Krall

As for Scotty, he spends his time with the film’s best new character, a zebra-striped, kickboxing alien called Jaylah (Sofia Boutella, from the awesome Kingsman: The Secret Service). She’s the keeper of their ticket off Altamid. She’s also keeper of a major grudge against the film’s big villain.

He (or she, who’s to say in outer space?) is Krall, a generic sci-fi bad guy played by Idris Elba in layers of prosthetics that obscure the face of one this generation’s most commanding actors. Krall, who unleashed the “bees” that destroyed the Enterprise, is in pursuit of some powerful metallic doodad of convoluted provenance (let’s call it Steve). He wants to unleash Steve on an enormous space station called Yorktown, which looks like the space station from Elysium if designed by M.C. Escher.

Kirk is, naturally, the only person who can stop Steve from destroying Yorktown, and if there’s one thing you can count on in these new Star Trek films is an incoherent action climax that undercuts the goodwill built up over the previous 100 minutes. That’s not to say Justin Lin isn’t a fine action director: He’s not a showoff, and he (and his four editors) knows when a wide shot is needed to reestablish our geography.

But if you’ve seen one climatic mano a mano in a Star Trek reboot, you’ve seen one too many. And a previous action sequence involving Kirk’s ride on a vintage motorcycle is just a trailer-ready play to the Fast and Furious crowd. (Abrams’ Star Trek films do love their vintage artifacts, especially music. But they feel more affected than plausible.)

Death casts a pall

Star Trek Beyond ultimately works because of the smaller moments involving a crew (in front of and behind the camera) finally shaking off the pressures of franchise-launching and starting to gel.

The film begins with Kirk lamenting the crew’s 966th day in monotonous, endless space, a condition he describes cheekily as “episodic.” We’re also treated to seeing Kirk glumly celebrate his birthday, reminded that he has now outlived his father. Indeed, there is a pall over Star Trek Beyond, not all of it the film’s making.

The movie is dedicated to the late Anton Yelchin (playing Chekov for the last time) and Leonard Nimoy. The death of Spock is referenced as a way to advance the film’s low-hanging fruit of a theme: The importance of family.

After Star Trek II’s melancholy treatise on aging, Star Trek IV’s environmental messaging, and the Cold War allegory of Star Trek VI, we’ve got a sequel too timid to run with the unfortunate opportunity it was given to really be about something. Too risky nowadays, a thought one presumes emanated from a Paramount boardroom.

Star Trek Beyond John Cho as gay SuluStar Trek Beyond with John Cho as the gay Sulu.

Problematic gay Sulu

If any risk was taken in Star Trek Beyond it’s the outing of Sulu (John Cho). Showing a major Star Trek character in a same sex relationship is certainly in line with original series creator Gene Rodenberry’s vision of a utopian future.

And some audience members might see a beloved character as a healthy, loving gay man and think twice about their own prejudices. But dramatically, seeing Sulu cast his worried eyes over his partner and their child is problematic.

Let’s face it, after 50 years we know next to nothing about the personal lives of the Enterprise crew and what little we know of the new cast has yet to be dramatized with any depth. So the noble thought of outing a major character feels like a calculated, rushed, and awkward statement-making, no matter how well-meaning the statement might be.

The idea would have been better served had it been more fully explored and folded into its family-first theme.

Most satisfying entry

But such is the fate of these shiny, new films, of which Star Trek Beyond is the most satisfying because it isn’t trying as hard as the previous two.

The corporate imperatives for action over character are there and as troublesome as ever, but Chris Pine and company are shedding the baggage of previous iterations and putting their own modest stamp on the franchise. Their flaws we’ll just chalk up to part of their charm.

And if nothing else, it’s a pleasure to know that Star Trek lives on – and is worth fussing over – after half a century.

Star Trek Beyond (movie 2016) cast & crew

Director: Justin Lin.

Screenplay: Simon Pegg & Doug Jung.
From the television series Star Trek, created by Gene Roddenberry.

Chris Pine … Captain James T. Kirk
Zachary Quinto … Commander Spock
Karl Urban … Doctor ‘Bones’ McCoy
Zoe Saldana … Lieutenant Uhura
Simon Pegg … Montgomery ‘Scotty’ Scott
John Cho … Sulu
Anton Yelchin … Chekov
Idris Elba … Krall
Sofia Boutella … Jaylah
Joe Taslim … Manas
Lydia Wilson … Kalara
Deep Roy … Keenser
Melissa Roxburgh … Ensign Syl
Anita Brown … Tyvanna
Doug Jung … Ben
Danny Pudi … Fi’Ja
Kim Kold … Zavanko
Fraser Aitcheson … Hider
Jeff Bezos … Starfleet Official

Cinematography: Stephen F. Windon.

Film Editing: Greg D’Auria, Dylan Highsmith, Kelly Matsumoto, and Steven Sprung.

Music: Michael Giacchino.

Producers: J.J. Abrams, Justin Lin, Roberto Orci, and Lindsey Weber.

Production Design: Thomas Sanders.

Costume Design: Sanja Milkovic Hays (as Sanja Hays).

Production Companies: Skydance Media | Alibaba Pictures | Huahua Media | Bad Robot | Sneaky Shark | Perfect Storm Entertainment.

Distributor: Paramount Pictures.

Running Time: 122 min.

Countries: United States | China.

Star Trek Beyond (Movie 2016)” notes

Star Trek Beyond movie credits via the British Film Institute (BFI) website.

See also: With the assistance of an outstanding Michael Fassbender, Ridley Scott recaptures some of the original Alien’s horror in Alien: Covenant.

See also: Tom Hanks embodies Clint Eastwood’s American Hero Fetish in the real-life-based drama Sully.

Chris Pine, Anton Yelchin, and John Cho in Star Trek Beyond movie images: Paramount Pictures.

Star Trek Beyond (Movie 2016): Problematic Gay Sulu” last updated in April 2023.

Recommended for You

Leave a Comment

*IMPORTANT*: By using this form you agree with Alt Film Guide's storage and handling of your data (e.g., your IP address). Make sure your comment adds something relevant to the discussion: Feel free to disagree with us and write your own movie commentaries, but *thoughtfulness* and *at least a modicum of sanity* are imperative. Abusive, inflammatory, spammy/self-promotional, baseless (spreading mis- or disinformation), and just plain deranged comments will be zapped. Lastly, links found in submitted comments will generally be deleted.


Mike -

Though I really like Star Trek Beyond, the more I watch it the more bad ideas for the movie I see. The most outstanding is the fall from the cliff with the Franklin, though true to a point there needed to be a ramp for the upward lift to help with the thrusters to lift the Franklin, instead of a sudden lift by the thrusters. The Franklin was going to fast facing down for the thrusters to work. Then the swarm, where did they all come from, when they attacked the Enterprise there wasen’t that many that attacked the Yorktown, and during the attack on the Yorktown there wasen’t that many the Franklin destroyed in the wave. In making a great movie for the youth you made blunders. I know what I’ll do, I’ll sit here and write down all the blundering ideas there are in the movie. In the series Suki wasen’t gay he flirted with women on different occasions. The one who didn’t have much of a idea of sexual preference was Chekov

Freddy Murrieta -

Fortunately though, this latest “episode” of the film franchise stands out as an energetic entry that is so packed with action and humor that it’s hard not to enjoy it.

Austin Scheller -

Enjoyable, astute article. I was glad the plot of this movie was essentially self-contained and not dependent on pre-existing lore in the manner of Into Darkness. The primary villain was good, but the script really could have profitably explored him more. Elba is such a fine actor, and his character’s philosophy is an interesting one. As for Sulu, I admire the filmmakers for making him gay or bisexual. I agree that it was a very Roddenberry touch.

Scribbling Geek -

I commented this elsewhere too. If not for the publicity, I wouldn’t have even assume that guy was Sulu’s husband. I would have thought he was a brother or relative.

And so, yeah. Queer inclusion, no pun intended. Overall, Sulu felt so tame in this installment too.


This website uses cookies to improve your experience. If you continue browsing, that means you've accepted our Terms of Use/use of cookies. You may also click on the Accept button on the right to make this notice disappear. Accept Read More