Alt Film Guide
Classic movies. Gay movies. International cinema. Socially conscious & political cinema.
Home Film ArticlesMovie Reviews The Aviator (Movie 2004): Excellent and Miscast Leonardo DiCaprio in Bloated Biopic

The Aviator (Movie 2004): Excellent and Miscast Leonardo DiCaprio in Bloated Biopic

The Aviator movie Leonardo DiCaprioThe Aviator movie with Leonardo DiCaprio: At times looking like a young Orson Welles, DiCaprio plays disturbed billionaire entrepreneur, flyer, and sometime film producer Howard Hughes in Martin Scorsese’s big-budget biopic.
  • The Aviator (movie 2004) review: Martin Scorsese takes the Steven Spielberg route in this costly, glitzy, superficial, and bloated biopic about all-American billionaire entrepreneur and sociopath Howard Hughes.
  • Texan drawl or no, Leonardo DiCaprio is miscast as the title character, for he doesn’t bring to mind the real-life Hughes. Paradoxically, DiCaprio is fully convincing as a charismatic, obsessive, deeply disturbed individual.
  • The Aviator won five Academy Awards, including Best Supporting Actress (Cate Blanchett) and Best Cinematography (Robert Richardson).[1]

The Aviator (movie 2004) review: Martin Scorsese has way too much fun with glitzy + bloated Howard Hughes biopic

Ramon Novarro biography Beyond Paradise

Imagine Orson Welles’ Citizen Kane, the fictionalized account of the life and times of publishing magnate William Randolph Hearst, directed by the serious-minded Steven Spielberg of The Color Purple, Schindler’s List, Amistad, and Saving Private Ryan. The final result would likely resemble Warner Bros./Miramax’s The Aviator, the fictionalized account of the life and times of the eccentric (i.e., mentally unbalanced), all-American billionaire entrepreneur, flyer, and ladies’ man Howard Hughes.

Strangely enough, the person who directed the superficial, phony, bloated The Aviator wasn’t Spielberg.

Was it then Barry Levinson, of the equally glitzy, superficial, and phony Bugsy, the fictionalized account of the life and times of mobster Bugsy Siegel?


The man behind The Aviator is Martin Scorsese, whose credits mostly consist of – however flawed – gritty dramas like Taxi Driver, Goodfellas, and Gangs of New York.

Now, when it comes to The Aviator, what made it go off the rails?

What’s not good for the Spruce Goose…

A fan of Old Hollywood, Martin Scorsese apparently wanted to have some fun with the reported $110 million budget made available to him. The director no doubt had a ball while making The Aviator, but whether he has been able to impart that joie de filmmaking to most moviegoers is debatable.

Clocking in at 169 minutes, The Aviator tries to stay aloft, but like Howard Hughes’ much-too-big and much-too-heavy Spruce Goose (a.k.a. The Hercules), this cinematic jumbo can only keep itself in the air for a few minutes at a time.

Miscast performers, a yearning to turn the tortured protagonist into a (somewhat) conventional film hero, and an excess of glitz – so we won’t notice the narrative’s lack of substance – pull The Aviator down each time after take-off.

Miscast yet excellent Leonardo DiCaprio

Scorsese and screenwriter John Logan begin their tale by having us witness the post-bath boy Howard Hughes (Jacob Davich) being dried by his weird mom (Amy Sloan), who also wants to make sure he can spell the word “quarantine.”

That moment comes across as a simple-minded and, really, wholly unnecessary “explanation” for the adult Hughes’ obsession/issues with women and germs. Things don’t get any subtler from then on.

By the late 1920s, Jacob Davich has grown into aspiring Hollywood mogul Leonardo DiCaprio,[2] who happens to be one of the best actors around, but who looks like he would be more comfortable starring in “The Orson Welles Story.”

Although DiCaprio’s performance in and of itself is flawless – he’s altogether convincing as an obsessive, profoundly disturbed man – the Titanic and Catch Me If You Can actor simply doesn’t look the part.

Ramon Novarro biography Beyond Paradise

For instance, when paired with Cate Blanchett’s irritatingly mannered Katharine Hepburn,[3] DiCaprio looks (and sounds) like her adenoidal offspring. He looks just as boyishly helpless next to Kate Beckinsale (as Ava Gardner) and Kelli Garner (as Faith Domergue) – neither of whom, by the way, look at all like the actresses they’re supposed to be portraying.

The Aviator movie Leonardo DiCaprio Cate BlanchettThe Aviator movie with Leonardo DiCaprio and Cate Blanchett: The former is perfect as a disturbed individual – though he’s not Howard Hughes. The latter is painfully inadequate as RKO star and future multiple Best Actress Oscar winner Katharine Hepburn.

Hypochondriacal sex animal

Not helping matters, John Logan’s screenplay fails to delve into Howard Hughes’ labyrinthine psyche.

As a result, it’s mystifying to see how Hughes could be a hypochondriacal freak – e.g., even afraid of touching door handles lest he catch a bug – and be ever so willing to exchange bodily fluids with stars and starlets alike.

Besides, Hughes is hardly averse at risking his life in other ways, becoming a record-smashing flying ace and later getting TWA off the ground much to the dismay of rival Juan Trippe (Alec Baldwin), the head of Pan Am.

Just as mind-boggling is how Hughes’ lapse into depression following a horrific plane crash in the mid-1940s is miraculously cured after Ava Gardner shows up to give him a good shave.

‘Average billionaire’ hero

Later in the film, issues such as Howard Hughes’ immeasurable power (and his hunger for more, more, more) and his unsavory ties to the U.S. government are surreptitiously brushed aside so Scorsese and Logan can focus instead on by-the-book movie battles pitting the go-getting hero against a couple of villains: Production Code censor Joseph Breen (Edward Herrmann), who wants to ban/shred Hughes’ voyeuristic Western The Outlaw, and crooked, Pan Am-supporting Republican senator Ralph Owen Brewster (gutsily played by eventual Best Supporting Actor Oscar nominee Alan Alda).

Even The Outlaw, whose chief focus is Jane Russell’s cleavage, offers more depth and more complex delineations. (Really, what goes on between Walter Huston’s Doc Holliday and Jack Buetel’s Billy the Kid?)

Ironically, as far as this reviewer is concerned the most stirring, most memorable moment in Scorsese and Logan’s The Aviator isn’t the (admittedly impressive) aerial battle at the beginning, or the plane crash later on, or any of the interpersonal goings-on.

Instead, it’s the brief footage from Howard Hughes’ own Hell’s Angels – made 75 years ago for about 1/10th (inflation-adjusted) of The Aviator’s budget.

The Aviator (movie 2004) cast & crew

Director: Martin Scorsese.

Screenplay: John Logan.

Cast: Leonardo DiCaprio (as Howard Hughes). Cate Blanchett (as Katharine Hepburn). Kate Beckinsale (as Ava Gardner). Alan Alda (as Senator Ralph Owen Brewster). Alec Baldwin (as Pan Am honcho Juan Trippe). Kelli Garner (as Faith Domergue). Gwen Stefani (as Jean Harlow). Ian Holm. Adam Scott. Jude Law (as Errol Flynn). Frances Conroy. Willem Dafoe. Jacob Davich (as the boy Howard Hughes). Edward Herrmann (as censor Joseph Breen). Danny Huston. John C. Reilly (as Howard Hughes’ business empire CEO Noah Dietrich). Stanley DeSantis (as Louis B. Mayer). Amy Sloan (as Howard Hughes’ mother). Kenneth Welsh. Rufus Wainwright. Kevin O’Rourke (as Spencer Tracy). Heather Petrone (as Vivien Leigh). Michael-John Wolfe (as Cary Grant).
Cameo: Lawrence of Arabia and Murder on the Orient Express editor Anne V. Coates (as one of Howard Hughes’ film editors).

The Aviator Cate Blanchett (Katharine Hepburn) Leonardo DiCaprio (Howard Hughes)The Aviator movie with Cate Blanchett as Katharine Hepburn and Leonardo DiCaprio as Howard Hughes.

The Aviator (Movie 2004)” notes

The Aviator awards

[1] In addition to Best Supporting Actress and Best Cinematography, The Aviator topped the following Academy Award categories: Film Editing (Thelma Schoonmaker), Art Direction (Dante Ferretti & set decorator Francesca Lo Schiavo), and Costume Design (Sandy Powell).

The Aviator was also shortlisted in six other Oscar categories: Best Picture, Director, Actor (Leonardo DiCaprio), Supporting Actor (Alan Alda), Original Screenplay, and Sound Mixing.

Among The Aviator’s other awards season wins were four BAFTAs, including Best Film and Best Supporting Actress (Cate Blanchett); the Screen Actors Guild Award for Best Supporting Actress (Blanchett); and the Producers Guild Award for Outstanding Producer of Theatrical Motion Pictures.

Ramon Novarro biography Beyond Paradise

Also: Three Golden Globes (Best Motion Picture – Drama, Best Actor – Drama, Best Score); the London Film Critics Circle’s Director of the Year Award; and the Los Angeles Film Critics Association Award for Best Production Design.

In addition, The Aviator was one of the National Board of Review’s Top Ten Films.

Of note, even though Robert Richardson won the Best Cinematography Oscar, the winner of the American Society of Cinematographers Award was Bruno Delbonnel for A Very Long Engagement.

Hollywood indie mogul Howard Hughes

[2] The Aviator movie hero Howard Hughes was credited for the direction of two features: Hell’s Angels (1930) and The Outlaw (filmed in 1941; briefly released in 1943; wide release in 1946). An uncredited Howard Hawks (Best Director Oscar nominee for Sergeant York, 1941) also had a hand on the latter.

As the head of the independent outlet The Caddo Company, Hughes produced 10 features between 1926 and 1932. Besides Hell’s Angels, notable titles include the gangster dramas The Racket (1928) and Scarface (1932), and the comedies Two Arabian Knights (1927) and The Front Page (1931).

Both The Racket and The Front Page were shortlisted for the Best Picture Academy Award. As the director of Two Arabian Knights, Lewis Milestone was the only individual to win an Academy Award in the short-lived Best Direction of a Comedy category.

While heading – and wrecking – RKO Pictures from 1948 to 1955, Howard Hughes was personally involved in the making of a handful of films, including Vendetta (1950), which was supposed to have turned Faith Domergue into a star, and the ill-fated The Conqueror (1956), starring John Wayne and Susan Hayward.

Howard Hughes’ actresses

[3] Although not seen in The Aviator, among the other actresses associated with Howard Hughes – whether as romantic partners or as the focus of his attentions – were Billie Dove, Ginger Rogers, Gene Tierney, Hedy Lamarr, Janet Leigh, Gina Lollobrigida, and sisters Olivia de Havilland and Joan Fontaine.

Hughes married Fox star Jean Peters (Pickup on South Street, Three Coins in the Fountain) in 1957. They would divorce in 1971.

Terry Moore (Best Supporting Actress Oscar nominee for Come Back Little Sheba, 1952) claimed she and Hughes were married at a 1949 ceremony performed by a ship captain in international waters. As there was no divorce, that would have made her the billionaire’s de facto widow upon his death in 1976.

Moore’s marriage claim was never legally recognized, but she and the Hughes estate would reach an undisclosed out-of-court settlement. She gets a Thank You credit in The Aviator.

Michael Mann was to have directed The Aviator. Instead, he ended up as one of the film’s producers. And Leonardo DiCaprio was to have starred in Mann’s Public Enemies, but the lead male roles ultimately went to Johnny Depp and Christian Bale.

Leonardo DiCaprio as Howard Hughes and Cate Blanchett as Katharine Hepburn The Aviator movie images: Miramax | Warner Bros.

The Aviator (Movie 2004): Excellent and Miscast Leonardo DiCaprio in Bloated Biopic” last updated in April 2023.

Recommended for You

Leave a Comment

*IMPORTANT*: By using this form you agree with Alt Film Guide's storage and handling of your data (e.g., your IP address). Make sure your comment adds something relevant to the discussion: Feel free to disagree with us and write your own movie commentaries, but *thoughtfulness* and *at least a modicum of sanity* are imperative. Abusive, inflammatory, spammy/self-promotional, baseless (spreading mis- or disinformation), and just plain deranged comments will be zapped. Lastly, links found in submitted comments will generally be deleted.


Joseph Kearny -

Agreed. It’s dreadful. Is box office clout the reason Scorsese keeps miscasting DiCaprio? He was also bad and wrong for The Departed another dreadful Scorsese film. Blanchett is nothing like Hephurn.

Bill B. -

I mostly agree. I think the movie very phony looking, superficial, way too long and extremely overrated. DiCaprio, not among my favorite actors, is simply totally miscast here & is in over his head, though I think Blanchette is okay in a tough to tackle role. I am among the few that is not among the Scorsese worshipers. Needless to say, he is very talented, but as the years roll by, he seems to admire his own work so much that he can’t seem to cut making nearly all of his more recent films overlong to the point that they wear out their welcome well before their actual ending. I long for him to return to his early creativity.

Gustavo -

The anti-Spielberg bias of this site is seriously affecting the quality of the work in display here. This text is nothing but a provocation full of strawman fallacies – Spielberg has never made a biopic, or any kind of movie, remotely similar to The Aviator in style or even content.

Maxim -

The opening of this review is as unfair as it is misguided (and the use of the word “would” borders on a provocation). Spielberg does not deal in superficiality or needless glitz. His dramatic work delivers on multiple levels, not the least of which is realism and substance. And imaging him taking on a big figure, be it Kane or upcoming Lincoln, carries nothing if not a promise of thoroughness and greatness. The cheap shots are just that and, frankly, any review that feels it needs to grab attention in such a hyperbolic and inflexible way does little to make the review appear worth taking seriously.

And that’s not going into how it sells the wonderfully unpredictable Barry Levenson short. Ever seen The Diner or Avalon?

Nathan Donarum -

I think Raging Bull is probably Scorsese’s best film, at least in terms of his directorial achievement. It’s really a brilliant character study. I need to watch it again as well, but I was blown away the first time I saw it.

Nathan Donarum -

I’m actually surprised that I agree with a lot of the points you make here. I actually enjoyed The Aviator quite a lot. But then again I admit to being biased when it comes to Scorsese, who’s admittedly my favorite filmmaker of all time. I also agree with you that DiCaprio is one of the most talented actors today. Which makes it difficult for me to admit that this movie does, in fact, have a number of (if we’re being honest) pretty obvious flaws. I especially take your point about understanding Hughes psyche to heart. I think this is perhaps the key flaw of the movie, but a flaw that for me doesn’t derail what is otherwise an entertaining film.

Scorsese has a tendency to explore characters who are on the outside, who don’t completely fit in with their environment, with the people around them. One need look no further than Travis Bickle. Even Henry Hill, who it could be argued was completely a part of his world, makes it clear that he can’t be: he’s half Irish, and can never be a made man.

Now look at Howard Hughes, who is again of that type. Perhaps it would have been a more compelling and more Scorsesian film if we got a movie about Hughes from a more psychological point of view. But regardless, I think Scorsese weaves a grand story, and personally, I found the 169 minutes more than bearable. I think the point overall is that, as you say, Scorsese was seeing what he could do with a huge budget. Even if it’s not a complete success, nor one of his best movies, I still find it to be more entertaining than the majority of junk Hollywood craps out on a weekly basis.

Leonardo -

I watched The Departed at the movies by myself, leaving my husband at home with our two girls. He is a wonderful actor without over exposing himself. I like that very much about him, not to mention he is hot.


This website uses cookies to improve your experience. If you continue browsing, that means you've accepted our Terms of Use/use of cookies. You may also click on the Accept button on the right to make this notice disappear. Accept Read More