Alt Film Guide
Classic movies. Gay movies. International cinema. Socially conscious & political cinema.
Home Movie Festivals Valkyrie: Tom Cruise Film Receives ‘Muted Praise’ in Germany

Valkyrie: Tom Cruise Film Receives ‘Muted Praise’ in Germany

Valkyrie film Tom Cruise Count Claus Schenk von Stauffenberg: Man wanted to kill Hitler
Valkyrie film with Tom Cruise as Count Claus Schenk von Stauffenberg, the man who wanted to kill Adolf Hitler. The failed plot to assassinate the German Führer led to von Stauffenberg’s execution at age 36 in July 1944, less than a year before the end of World War II in Europe.[1]

Bryan Singer-Tom Cruise collaboration Valkyrie receives ‘muted praise’ from German critics

Ramon Novarro biography Beyond Paradise

Directed by Bryan Singer and starring Tom Cruise, the World War II drama Valkyrie is scheduled to open in the U.S. on Christmas Day 2008. The Singer-Cruise collaboration, however, has already had its New York City premiere, and apparently has been seen by at least some German critics.

Below is a snippet from the article “Muted Praise for Valkyrie from German Critics” found in Der Spiegel:

“How could [Tom] Cruise, the all-American action hero, play Germany’s only hero of the 20th century, Count Claus Schenk von Stauffenberg, the man who came close to killing Hitler and ending World War II on July 20, 1944? Cruise’s membership in the Church of Scientology, seen by German authorities as little more than a money-making operation, fuelled doubts about his suitability.

“Now Valkyrie, named after the plot by German military officers to overthrow the Nazi leadership, has had its world premiere in New York, and German film critics are less damning than might have been expected.”

‘Logistical cinematographic effort’

One Valkyrie review quoted in the article is from the Munich-based newspaper Süddeutsche Zeitung:

“Measured in terms of all the things the film was accused of, measured in terms of all that could have gone wrong, one can almost call it a triumph. It’s definitely the most exciting, realistic and complex feature film about July 20, even if the benchmark – three German attempts between 1955 and 2004 – wasn’t unattainably high.

“One can also say that Hollywood has never taken such a thoroughly German issue as seriously as it has with this opulent, logistical cinematographic effort.”

Der Spiegel‘s report adds that even though Tom Cruise’s performance was criticized for being “wooden and low-key,” the supporting cast, including Kenneth Branagh and Tom Wilkinson, was generally praised.

‘Valkyrie’ cast

The three aforementioned Valkyrie cast members have all been Oscar nominees in the last two decades:

  • Tom Cruise: as Best Actor, Born on the Fourth of July (1989) and Jerry Maguire (1996); as Best Supporting Actor, Magnolia (1999).
  • Kenneth Branagh: as Best Actor and Best Director, Henry V (1989); as director of the nominated Live Action Short Swan Song (1992); in the Best Adapted Screenplay category, Hamlet (1996).
  • Tom Wilkinson: as Best Actor, In the Bedroom (2001); as Best Supporting Actor, Michael Clayton (2007).

Also in the Valkyrie cast:

Bill Nighy. Carice van Houten. Thomas Kretschmann. Eddie Izzard. Kevin McNally. Jamie Parker.

Christian Berkel. Tom Hollander. David Schofield. David Bamber (as Adolf Hitler). Matthias Schweighöfer.

Veteran Terence Stamp (The Collector, The Adventures of Priscilla, Queen of the Desert).

The screenplay is credited to Christopher McQuarrie (The Usual Suspects) and tyro Nathan Alexander.

The man who wanted to kill Hitler: Claus Schenk von Stauffenberg movies

[1] As found on the IMDb, Claus Schenk von Stauffenberg has been seen on the big screen six times prior to Tom Cruise and Valkyrie:

  • Eduard Franz in The Desert Fox: The Story of Rommel (1951).
  • Bernhard Wicki’s It Happened on July 20th / Es geschah am 20. Juli (1955).
  • Wolfgang Preiss in The Plot to Assassinate Hitler / Der 20. Juli (1955).
  • William Sargent in Hitler (1962).
  • Gérard Buhr in The Night of the Generals (1967).
  • Stephan Jacobs in Rommel and the Plot to Kill Hitler (2006).

On television, notable Claus Schenk von Stauffenberg portrayers include Brad Davis in The Plot to Kill Hitler (1990) and Sebastian Koch in Operation Valkyrie (2004).

And finally, Walter Pidgeon played a fictional (British) would-be Hitler assassin in Fritz Lang’s 1941 Hollywood thriller Man Hunt, released during World War II (prior to the U.S. entry into the war).

Masquerades Lyès Salem Mohamed Bouchaïb Sarah Reguieg: Best Film winner
Masquerades with Lyès Salem, Mohamed Bouchaïb, and Sarah Reguieg. Directed, co-written (with Nathalie Saugeon), and starring Lyès Salem, the 2008 Dubai Film Festival’s Best Film winner is a French/Algerian comedy about an Algerian man (Lyès Salem) eager to find a husband for his narcoleptic, would-be spinster sister (Sarah Reguieg).

Dubai Film Festival winners

The Best Film at the 2008 Dubai Film Festival, held Dec. 11–18, was Lyès Salem’s Algerian/French comedy Masquerades / Mascarades, in which an arrogant man (played by Salem) living with his family in an Algerian village has one dream: to be respected by those around him. The problem is that he has a narcoleptic sister whom everyone believes will end up a spinster.

To resolve the issue, the man tells everyone that he has found a rich suitor for his sister so that preparations for the marriage can begin. But now there’s another problem: where’s the bridegroom?

Written by Salem and Nathalie Saugeon, Masquerades is Algeria’s submission for the 2009 Best Foreign Language Film Academy Award.

See below the list of 2008 Dubai Film Festival winners.

Muhr Arabic Features

Best Film
Masquerades, dir.: Lyès Salem, Algeria / France.

Special Jury Prize
Adhen Dernier Maquis, dir.: Rabah Ameur-zaimeche, Algeria / France.

Best Actors
Anas Elbaz & Omar Lotfi for Casanegra, Morocco.

Best Actress
Hifsia Herzi for Française, France / Morocco.

Best Screenplay
Annemarie Jacir for Salt of This Sea, Palestine.

Best Cinematographer
Luca Coassin for Casanegra.

Best Editor
Nicolas Bancilhon for Adhen Dernier Maquis.

Best Composer
Sylvain Rifflet for Adhen Dernier Maquis.

FIPRESCI (International Film Critics) Award
Masquerades, dir.: Lyès Salem.

First Prize
Memory of the Cactus: A Story of Three Palestinian Villages, dir.: Hanna Musleh, Palestine.

Special Jury Prize
The One Man Village / Samaan Bidiyaa, dir.: Simon El Habre, Lebanon.

Second Prize
Marina of the Zabbaleen, dir.: Engi Wassef, Egypt / USA.

Short Films

First Prize
The North Road / La Route du nord, dir.: Carlos Chahine, Lebanon / France.

Special Jury Prize
Bint Mariam, dir.: Saeed Salmeen Al-murry, United Arab Emirates.

Second Prize
At Day’s End / Sa’et Asary, dir.: Sherif El Bendary, Egypt.

Muhr Asia-Africa Features

Best Film
Treeless Mountain, dir.: So Yong Kim, USA / South Korea.

Special Jury Prize
Vacation / Kyuka, dir.: Hajime Kadoi, Japan.

Best Actor
Askhat Kuchinchirekov for Tulpan.

Best Actress
Anh Hong for Moon at the Bottom of the Well / Trang Noi Day Gieng, Vietnam.

Best Screenplay
Deepa Mehta for Heaven on Earth, Canada.

Best Cinematographer
Reza Teymouri for Be Calm and Count to Seven, Iran.

Best Composer
Jorja Mesafin, Vigay Iyer for Teza, Ethiopia / Germany / France.

Best Editor
Sreekar Prasad for Firaaq, India.


First Prize
Mental, dir.: Kazuhiro Soda, Japan / USA.

Special Jury Prize
Survival Song, dir.: Guangyi Yu, China.

Second Prize
Black Business / Une Affaire de negres, dir.: Osvalde Lewat, Cameroon.

Short Films

First Prize
Young Blood, dir.: Haolun Shu, China.

Shorts Special Jury Prize
Expectations, dir.: Mahamat-saleh Haroun, Chad / Korea.

Second Prize
Everything Is OK / Kam Sanabanyz, dir.: Akjoltoy Bekbolotov, Kyrgyzstan.

Best Emirati Talent

Best UAE talent: Haydar Mohammed.

Most promising UAE female filmmaker: Nujoom Al Ghanem.

Most promising UAE male filmmaker: Saeed Salmeen Al-Murry.

I Sell the Dead: Glenn McQuaid horror black comedy opens Slamdance Film FestivalI Sell the Dead with Dominic Monaghan and Larry Fessenden. Slamdance 2009 Opening Night Film I Sell the Dead is a horror/black comedy directed by Glenn McQuaid, and featuring Dominic Monaghan, Ron Perlman, Angus Scrimm, and Larry Fessenden.

Slamdance Film Festival: What Utah boycott?

The 2009 Slamdance Film Festival will take place in Park City, Utah, between Jan. 15–23.

Utah?? The Prop. 8 Mormon State??

As far as we can tell, Slamdancers haven’t been attacked by those who have been going for the throat of Sundance Film Festival organizers. Perhaps the fact that calls for a Slamdance boycott would have attracted considerably less media coverage has something to do with it.

In any case, Slamdance 2009 will screen approximately 100 films, with 20 of those in the narrative and documentary feature competition categories, which are supposed to showcase movies without domestic theatrical distribution, with budgets under $1 million, and from first-time feature film directors.

Unusual corpses in place of the usual Hollywood stars

Unlike what will be available at Sundance 2009, chances are you won’t find motion pictures starring Susan Sarandon, Pierce Brosnan, and other top names in the Slamdance competition.

Slamdance 2009’s Opening Night Film is writer-director Glenn McQuaid’s horror/black comedy I Sell the Dead, toplining Dominic Monaghan, Ron Perlman, Angus Scrimm, and Larry Fessenden (who also produced it). Set in the late 1800s, I Sell the Dead follows a couple of grave robbers who begin to unearth some unusual corpses.

Slamdance 2009 programming

In addition to the five programming sections – Narrative Features, Documentaries, Special Screenings, Twilight Screenings, and Shorts – Slamdance 2009 will also present the following:

  • Four writing competitions: feature screenplay, teleplay, horror screenplay, and short screenplay.
  • The Anarchy Online Short Film Competition.
  • Fireside Chats.
  • A $99 Special short film production project.
  • And, for the first time, music videos.

Slamdance 2009 and its box office will be headquartered at the Treasure Mountain Inn, 255 Main Street, the festival’s base since 1998.

For more information and for a complete listing of screenings, visit the Slamdance Film Festival website or call 323/466-1786. Festival passes are now on sale on their website; individual tickets go on sale online Dec. 16.

Below is the list of Slamdance 2009 films with gay themes, and further down are the Documentary Feature Competition entries. Synopses via the Slamdance website.

City Rats Kenny Doughty: Slamdance gay moviesCity Rats with Kenny Doughty. Directed by Steve Kelly and written by Simon Fantauzzo, City Rats chronicles the emotional travails of a group of youthful urban dwellers. In the City Rats cast: Tamer Hassan, Ray Panthaki, Susan Lynch, Danny Dyer, Kenny Doughty, James Lance, MyAnna Buring, Natasha Williams, Richard Mylan, and Jake Canuso.

2009 Slamdance Film Festival gay-themed movies

City Rats (Feature Narrative Competition).
Steve M. Kelly (Director), Simon Fantauzzo (Writer) World Premiere, Drama, 2008, UK, 96 minutes. Cast: Susan Lynch, Kenny Doughty, Tamer Hassan. A modern day Dickensian tale of eight haunted people who meet and fall apart while searching for redemption in each other.

Mississippi Damned (Feature Narrative Competition).
Tina Mabry (Director/Writer). World Premiere, Drama, 2009, USA , 120 minutes. Cast: DB Woodside, Malcolm David Kelly, Malcolm Goodwin, Tessa Thompson, Michael Hyatt. Three poor Black kids in rural Mississippi reap the consequences of their family’s cycle of abuse, addiction, and violence.

Drool (Special Screening).
Nancy Kissam (Director/Writer). World Premiere, Drama, 2008, USA , 88 minutes. Cast: Laura Harring, Jill Marie Jones, Oded Fehr. An abused wife’s plan to escape her husband goes awry when she accidentally kills him, causing her to split on a cross-country drive with her best friend and his corpse in tow.

Dish (Short Film Competition).
Brian H. Krinksy, Writer/Director World Premiere / 2008 / USA / 15 minutes. High school buddies dish about their sex lives, classmates and hair.

Vapid Lovelies (Short Film Competition).
Frank Feldman, Writer/Director; David Luna and Chris Lemon, Writers World Premiere / 2008 / USA / 22 minutes. Two Middle-American gay fashionistas set out to create the perfect outfit Rock Pockets.

Slamdance Documentary Feature Competition

Graphic Sexual Horror
Barbara Bell & Anna Lorentzon (Directors/Writers).
World Premiere, 2009, USA , 85 minutes. A look behind the terrifying façade of, the most notorious of the ‘violent porn’ websites, while exploring the dark mind of its artistic creator and asking hard questions about personal responsibility.

Hard to Be an Indian
Beth Toni Kruvant (Director), Jonah Kruvant (Writer).
World Premiere, 2007, USA , 84 minutes. The trials and tribulations of an inner city school and the principal, Jewish alumni and gang members who return it to safety and restore its former glory.

Lost Sparrow
Chris Billing (Director/Writer).
World Premiere, 2009, USA , 78 minutes. Filmmaker Chris Billing probes at his family history while investigating the tragic 1978 deaths of his adopted Crow Indian brothers.

Oh My God, It’s Harrod Blank
David Silverberg (Director/Writer).
World Premiere, 2008, USA , 75 minutes. A portrait of the eccentric art-car artist Harrod Blank, following him from his youth in the woods to his current multi-faceted career as creator and head of a nationwide art-car movement. With appearances by his father, filmmaker Les Blank.

The Road to Fallujah
Mark Manning (Director/Writer).
World Premiere, 2009, USA , 85 minutes. Exploring Mark Manning’s unique access as the only westerner to live with the people of Fallujah immediately following the November 2004 battle that destroyed their ancient and holy city, offering an in-depth and humanizing look at current issues in Iraq.

Second Sight
Alison McAlpine (Director/Writer).
US Premiere, 2008, Scotland / Canada, 51 minutes. A cinematic, non-fiction ghost story featuring the last generation of Gaelic storytellers on Scotland’s Isle of Skye.

Smile Til It Hurts
Lee Storey (Director/Writer).
North American Premiere, 2009, USA , 81 minutes. The amazing true story of Up With People, the singing group that represented an establishment-friendly alternative to the counter-culture.

Zachary Levy (Director/Writer).
World Premiere, 2008, USA , 113 minutes. A man strong enough to bend a penny with just his fingers, Stanless Steel reaches middle age, career disappointments and difficult personal relationships that begin to test his strengths and force him to struggle with the weaknesses around him – including his own.

Unwanted Witness
Juan José Lozano (Director/Writer).
US Premiere, 2008, Switzerland / France, 87 minutes. In the middle of Colombia’s humanitarian tragedy, a journalist fights to report and disclose the barbarity of the conflict.

Zombie Girl
Justin Johnson, Aaron Marshall, Erik Mauck (Directors/Writers).
Utah Premiere, 2008, USA , 91 minutes. An inside look at the two years that it took 12-year-old Emily Hagins to write and direct her feature-length zombie movie, Pathogen.

Valkyrie movie cast info via the IMDb.

Tom Cruise Valkyrie image: United Artists / Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer.

Lyès Salem, Mohamed Bouchaïb, and Sarah Reguieg Masquerades image: Dharamsala.

Kenny Doughty City Rats image: Face Films / Urban Way Productions.

Dominic Monaghan and Larry Fessenden I Sell the Dead image: Glass Eye Pix.

Valkyrie: Tom Cruise Film Receives ‘Muted Praise’ in Germany + Gay Slamdance Entries & Dubai Winners” last updated in March 2018.

Recommended for You

Leave a Comment

*IMPORTANT*: By using this form you agree with Alt Film Guide's storage and handling of your data (e.g., your IP address). Make sure your comment adds something relevant to the discussion: Feel free to disagree with us and write your own movie commentaries, but *thoughtfulness* and *at least a modicum of sanity* are imperative. Abusive, inflammatory, spammy/self-promotional, baseless (spreading mis- or disinformation), and just plain deranged comments will be zapped. Lastly, links found in submitted comments will generally be deleted.


suse -

what’s with the no use of accents . . .???

with tom’s american, and the british guy — i’m CONFUSED! everybody’s got on a different uniform (no ss), were they suppose to be german or allies?

Gordie Chance -

I watched the movie last night. First, I think Bryan Singer did a wonderful job at directing the film. The movie was dramatic & had a good pace. The dialogue was outstanding as well. David Bamber’s portrayal of Hitler was credible and dynamic but perhaps his role was under utilized.

I thought Tom Cruise did a good job of acting. Any problem with his casting to the lead role was due to my own pre-conceived opinions that I brought to the film as a viewer. In all fairness to Mr. Cruise, the problem was with me not him.

I wish the film would have been done in German with English subtitles. Guillermo Del Toro’s “Pan’s Labyrinth” was a richer film because he used the native language.

I am glad the story is being re-told to another generation that needs to hear it, as do I.

rick allen -

What saddens me is the advertisiments for the movie, they only mention tom crusie but none of the other steller stars in it, i know cruise plays the key character in the whole movie, but so many others played other key roles in the whole plot to kill hitler, not just Claus Count Schenk von Stauffenberg. And im sure he gave the credit to those that helped him plan the plot and carry it out., the movie advertisement should give those steller actors the proper respect and mention, this is not just a tom cruise movie, this a movie with good solid based older actors such as …tom wilkinson, bill nighy, kenneth branaugh, terence stamp, and carise van houten, and so many more. at least in the tv preview ads mention those people , it isnt just a movie with tom cruise in it.

Bert -

You should see Graphic Sexual Horror, they are premiering at Slamdance this film and it is the most extreme documentary you will ever see.

Art, Freedom, Sex, Money, Torture, and the Evil Us Government Collide.


This website uses cookies to improve your experience. If you continue browsing, that means you've accepted our Terms of Use/use of cookies. You may also click on the Accept button on the right to make this notice disappear. Accept Read More